Preprint alert! End-to-end topographic networks as models of cortical map formation and human visual behaviour: moving beyond convolutions arxiv.org/abs/2308.09431v1 ๐Ÿงต 1/10

Aug 22, 2023 ยท 3:12 PM UTC

3
46
134
21,686
In this work, we introduce All-Topographic Neural Networks, which, when trained on visual data, capture topographic features of the visual system and human visual behaviour. With @lu_zejin, @__init_self, Daniel Kaiser, Radek Cichy and @TimKietzmann. 2/10
1
4
4
1,653
Background: CNNs are the most commonly used networks to model vision, and have been successful at predicting primate neural activity across multiple hierarchical levels and at accounting for complex visual behaviour. 3/10
1
1
3
719
One limitation of CNNs in neuroscience is their reliance on weight sharing, i.e., CNNs detect identical features across visual space. This renders them unable to model fundamental aspects of biological vision, such as the origin of topography and its relation to behaviour. 4/10
1
2
4
834
We overcome this limitation with end-to-end topographic networks (All-TNNs) in which: 1) each unit has its own local RF, 2) units in each layer are arranged on a 2D โ€œcortical sheetโ€ without weight sharing, and 3) feature selectivity varies smoothly across space. 5/10
1
5
7
1,701
Upon training, topographical features of the ventral stream emerge in All-TNNs (but not CNNs), including smooth orientation selectivity maps and cortical magnification in the first layer, and category-based selectivity clusters for tools, scenes, and faces in the last layer. 6/10
1
4
8
873
To study the impact of topography on behaviour, we conducted a human experiment to quantify object recognition performance across space. This yields category-dependent spatial accuracy maps for humans. 7/10
1
1
5
629
There is category-specific structure in these behavioural accuracy maps. On a variety of metrics, we find that all-TNNs better reproduce this behavioural structure than CNNs. 8/10
1
2
8
943
Finally, we show that the success of All-TNNs in reproducing human spatial biases in behaviour is directly linked to their topography. 9/10
1
1
4
686
In conclusion, All-TNNs are a promising new class of models, which address questions that are beyond the scope of CNNs, and could serve as more accurate models of functional organisation in the visual cortex and its behavioural consequences. 10/10
1
8
684
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
Replying to @AdrienDoerig
What are the interactions with in different units in a layer and across layers? Curious on how inter unit interactions were modeled...
1
1
87
All the details are in the paper, it's a bit long to explain on Twitter, but if you still have questions after reading the methods let me know!
1
184
Replying to @AdrienDoerig
Very cool work. Have you compared the All-TNN with topographic networks that use weight sharing? The paper shows benefits over models without a spatial loss, but what about a CNN trained with a spatial loss?
1
1
423
Good question, we haven't looked yet. The current developments are geared towards getting rid of all convolutional elements in the models, as we deem them hard to realise in biology, and topographic CNN models would still have identical features across spatial locations.
1
147