Gwynn is the name I want to argue for. He hit .394 in 1994 and the strike ended the season on August 11. He was 34 years old, and nobody has gotten that close since. Watching a man who almost never missed the ball is its own kind of entertainment, and it is a slower kind than this poll usually rewards. Griffey wins this one and probably should, because the swing is the most copied piece of footage in the sport, and no amount of arguing on my part is going to change that. Two of these guys are here for what they did before the decade even started, and I put them on the card anyway. Rickey was 31 in 1990 and led the American League in steals that year, again in 1991, and once more in 1998 at age 39. Ozzie was 35 and worth the ticket price on his own. Neither of them needed the decade to make the case.

Sep 6, 2026 · 4:46 PM UTC

30
7
84
9,914
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey. Especially, when he refers to himself in the third person.
2
49
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey. Electric on the basepaths and he gave opposing teams nightmares.
2
45
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Entertaining? Rickey being Rickey was worth the price of admission.
2
52
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey says the answer is Rickey
1
16
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Dude, I am with you 100%. I'm a Tiger fan forever, but other than that, Tony Gwynn was THE MAN as far as I'm concerned. He gets overlooked, I think, because he wasn't a power hitter but that never mattered to me. He was such a joy to watch.
1
38
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Griff of course
1
43
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey would have said that Rickey was the most entertaining.
5
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Tony Gwynn was a pure hitter. In 20 seasons he only struck out 434 times & never more than 40 times in one season He ended up with 534 doubles more than strikeouts
27
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
I had the privilege of watching them play. The best of any era.
5
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
All of them and just think about how far we’ve fallen. Baseball like America was just better back then. Rickey was probably the all around best player of all time
22
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
hard to argue those points - but I'd go with Ozzie - while he wasn't as consistent with the bat, but he was clutch - and NOBODY played defense with more style than him - not to mention his back flip entry to the field before the games
32
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Saw all of them in person. In my order; 1. Griffey 2. Ricky 3. Ozzie 4. Tony. Nothing beat the excitement of having Jr step up to the plate (Rose & Reggie the same).
28
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
T Gwynn. Loved watching him play. So smart
29
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Ozzie Smith?!? You gotta be kidding me - worth the ticket price on his own? Why for going 1-5 with a single and a good defensive play while his team lost - man you’re reaching on Ozzie
23
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
The Kid
14
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Bubble Gum Ice Cream Back Flips Patience & Discipline
12
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Offensive is Gwynn Defensive is Ozzie
34
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Slap hitters are boring
3
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Griffey Jr
44
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Ricky. And it ain’t close.
26
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey Henderson
6
Replying to @BBGreatMoments
Rickey! No one like him.
24