Immigration in Rentier Economy: Contradictions that Negate Past History
Libs and rightoids always boil down immigration to identity axioms and then pretend there is no economic dimension. Everything in American immigration policy was based on growth and the need for cheap labor for every part of American history in it's industrial age, end of story.
No fairy tales about the primacy of ontologies here, you need people to work in factories and populate a nation that had land and no people. Enough people, close the door. Not enough people, open the door.
Post 1960 you get the first contradiction: America radically de-industrializes in favor of finance and specifically the finance of war. After 1971 it's a fully floating de-industrialized "service based" rentier ponzi scheme driven by electronics, computers, the internet, and AI (so all "information").
It's consumptive side is all gambling porno shit coins and slop entertainment and obscene military spending. End of story.
Immigration at this point is integrally bound to consumptive economy. What does it mean to consume in a society that no longer produces anything and only produces half of what it consumes? Do we need more people now to substitute for growth in consumption when there is no hope of being productive overall in a society that prizes un-production through debt above all?
Are we growing the American population so China can manufacture what it needs to exist? Do we want people to come here to strengthen the Imperial system and partake in the re-vitalization of the dollar's increasing reliance on rentier mechanisms? Because we are below the replacement rate in population, do we need more people?
Door open or door closed these days means relatively little. It seems to have moved completely out of any concept of the base and is sustained totally from ideological wars within the superstructure. This is fundamentally abstract.
Corporations need cheap labor, sure, and my analysis of immigrants class and productive labor status proves they make up 1/3 of America's last productive proletarians - another pressure on labor to never organize when they are essentially an unofficial foreign labor force that dominates construction and agricultural work (some of the most important industiries).
But about 40% of immigrants work in the same service sector all Americans do, and their future is bleak. The concept of coming here to "have a better life" is absurd- they are here to partake in a ruthless shark tank of fleeting chances to become part of dollar rentier sinecure.
John Doyle shines a light on the glossed-over history of European (Irish, German, Polish, etc.) migration to America in the 19th and 20th century, which caused major problems for the native stock and was heavily cracked down on by the federal government.
@JohnDoyle