Center for Digital Democracy news about digital technologies and their impact on democracy, equity, fairness, community. @digitaldemoc.bsky.socia

Washington, D.C.
"The consequences of one-party rule at the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) are evident by the failure of the agency to fully understand the mechanisms behind surveillance pricing; its dramatic expansion across consumer-facing industries; adoption of far-reaching Generative AI & other technologies; and how it incorporates an array of powerful collaborator partners—including social media platforms, influencers, sophisticated data profiling and “Adtech” technologies that surround the consumer and direct their “path to purchase.” bit.ly/4yRGHwx"
Commercial surveillance pricing must be investigated & regulated @DigitalDemoc "If the Trump Adm. controlled FTC does not act to seriously protect Americans from the data surveillance leviathan that manipulates what they pay—at the store, pump, and interest from credit --it will leave millions of Americans at greater financial risk." Exposes role of Retail/Commerce Media apparatus. #privacy #consumerprotection; bit.ly/4yRGHwx
42
Commercial surveillance pricing must be investigated & regulated @DigitalDemoc "If the Trump Adm. controlled FTC does not act to seriously protect Americans from the data surveillance leviathan that manipulates what they pay—at the store, pump, and interest from credit --it will leave millions of Americans at greater financial risk." Exposes role of Retail/Commerce Media apparatus. #privacy #consumerprotection; bit.ly/4yRGHwx
58
What are your Gen AI safeguards @andystone, including Advantage+ & beyond, that truly protect youth beyond the modest (and long overdue) concessions you made to state AGs. Given the interest to monetize & engage youth, please tell how Meta will "step up" here with AI the core of everything it does. technologycoalition.org/abou…
We welcome TikTok to Lantern, the program Meta helped build to protect children online through industry collaboration. Now to truly keep teens safe, TikTok should step up and meet the standard we’ve set with the nation’s attorneys general.
64
This is a deal with State AGs that ignores the market realities of the global media biz. Gen AI will eradicate jobs & skill sets across #WarnerMount's workforce & divisions. The consent degree does nothing to curtail the power of the Ellison's & their backers across vast swaths of our media. The AGs got pennies today in this deal for the public; not a 21st Cent set of provisions.
1
1
40
The Paramount takeover of Warner's is a case study. Why we need a regulatory regime to deal with the commercial surveillance media & platform networks that control our information; have growing unchecked (AI) influence on public & whose allegiances are not anchored in democratic values.
42
The approval of the Ellison + middle east investors takeover of Warner's has huge consequences for US democracy. Underscores need for expanded role for advocates to expose policy/regulatory failures on antitrust, Adtech/AI systems, privacy, content diversity & need for new laws ensuring media pluralism.
1
32
Important Gen AI "safety" post of read.
The concerns articulated by current OpenAI employee Daniel Selsam are quite different from Jacob Coxon's. Dismayed to see this one get a 1/100 of the views
45
The backlash against digital media, big tech leaders, & the pols & lobbyists supporting it provides key moment for change. The social media addiction crisis, data center opposition & realistic fears of Gen AI dangerously out of control are linked. We need wise leaders & advocates worldwide mobilizing the public to enact regimes putting public first.
1
42
There's no question that if the U.S. had a working FTC, following what's going on--including privacy, consumer protection, competition--it could have helped protect the public from what we call commercial surveillance 3.0. So much to do, so few willing to stand up for public.
Law enforcers already have authority to charge companies and their CEOs for creating and releasing dangerous, unvetted, or defective products. We shouldn’t let discussions about new legal regimes distract from the fact that there’s no AI exemption from laws already on the books — a point @FTC emphasized repeatedly during my tenure. 1. There is an extensive set of laws that govern dangerous and defective products. For example, releasing unvetted AI models or agents can violate consumer protection laws. Shipping flawed AI tools without implementing adequate measures to detect and stop rogue or defective AI agents can be an “unfair or deceptive” act or practice under the FTC Act (and analogous state laws). And some state AGs are already exploring holding AI firms and their CEOs criminally liable when their models participate in criminal activity. 2. Existing laws also prohibit “unfair methods of competition.” This covers instances where AI firms appropriate the competitively sensitive information of their customers, including through tracking their use of various tools. It can also cover instances where firms pursue dangerous behavior, aware that doing so may compel rivals to do the same. As the Supreme Court has noted: “A method of competition which casts upon one's competitors the burden of the loss of business unless they will descend to a practice which they are under a powerful moral compulsion not to adopt, even though it is not criminal, was thought to involve the kind of unfairness at which the [unfair methods of competition] statute was aimed." 3. The highly concentrated and interconnected structure of these markets could be creating major risks and conflicts of interest. We had started investigating these partnerships and cross-investments across the stack (and released a preliminarily overview of some findings: ftc.gov/news-events/news/pre…). Both federal and state enforcers should be scrutinizing these opaque relationships and inter-dependencies. We are already seeing how these relationships could undermine accountability. For example, OpenAI could face liability given the Hugging Face incident, but Hugging Face being bought up by Nvidia means that we’re unlikely to see it file a lawsuit over this — given Nvidia’s strong incentive to see OpenAI continue full speed ahead. 4. As AI tools dramatically change the landscape of cybersecurity risks and hacks, all businesses should be doubling down on having core security protections in place. Firms that fail to invest in adequate data security measures or fix known vulnerabilities can also be breaking the law. A recent analysis showed that around 1/3 of Fortune 100 companies do not even have a way to notify them about security issues. During my @FTC tenure, we sued firms for poor data security practices and held CEOs liable when they were personally responsible. this.weekinsecurity.com/doze… ftc.gov/news-events/news/pre… 5. As policymakers consider new legal regimes, we should be looking to lessons from prior efforts to govern major sectors, such as banking and other networks, platforms, and utilities. Tools like structural separations, nondiscrimination, and supervision could be key, and there’s a rich history of what works and what doesn’t. But we can and must pursue any new efforts alongside enforcing existing laws.
41
The privacy work we did back in 1998 still paying dividends--inc. #Meta case. (allies inc. @EPICprivacy@ConsumerFed @GeorgetownLaw, many others). From law firm: "COPPA violations were central to the states' theory of liability. The agreement represents the largest COPPA-related enforcement outcome in the statute's history...Organizations should require vendors supplying platforms or applications that interact with minor users to represent compliance with COPPA…"
2
1
2
78
Gen Ai in finance must be regulated to protect public. States can help prevent consumer financial ripoffs & bad corporate acts. indebt.substack.com/p/a-few-…
27
Those concerned about social media & youth should see our new report on role of Gen AI, social media, marketing surveillance. The State AGs should "Call their Agentic" and ensure their deal is aligned with market realities. bit.ly/3Uie90w
Until the State AGs & regulators address the (now) Gen AI+data run ad & marketing systems of #Meta, Google, TikTok, big brands, young people will still be targets--despite whatever changes agreed to. We have a trillion dollar global ad economy, fueled by the biggest co's, luring youth (& everyone else), on every platform, to the increasingly agentic driven social media Siren.
48
Until the State AGs & regulators address the (now) Gen AI+data run ad & marketing systems of #Meta, Google, TikTok, big brands, young people will still be targets--despite whatever changes agreed to. We have a trillion dollar global ad economy, fueled by the biggest co's, luring youth (& everyone else), on every platform, to the increasingly agentic driven social media Siren.
55
“The settlement reaches the features of Meta’s platforms but not the engine that drives them. Meta earns nearly all of its money from advertising. Young people’s attention is the inventory it sells. Design that captures and holds that attention is not a flaw in the business model, it is the business model working as intended." Issues w/AG deal. bit.ly/4zE8qSB
1
96
If settlement @AGRobBonta doesn't address how #Meta actually engages youth & others via Gen AI, it has missed crucial opportunity for meaningful safeguards. ai.meta.com/learn/ai-creativ…
We’ve secured a proposed settlement with Meta that will significantly change how Instagram and Facebook interact with children and teens, and that will include a $17 billion payment. If the settlement is approved by the court, these changes include daily time limits, stopping notifications during school hours, blocks on nighttime use, banning dangerous filters, enhanced detection and removal of users under 13, and much more. Alongside a bipartisan coalition, I’m proud to deliver real transparency and real change to protect children’s and teens' mental health and support parents across the country. oag.ca.gov/news/press-releas…
79
When we lobbied to enact COPPA more than 25 years ago, we knew legal safeguards could protect kids from Big Tech harms. That said, if the #Meta AG settlement doesn't include Gen AI regulation, the harms raised by our new report will continue to threaten youth. Hopefully the settlement is looking forward--not back to older model of engagement. bit.ly/3Uie90w
2
57
The US DoJ TikTok settlement requires scrutiny in its era of Gen AI influencer operations.
33