Libertarianism in Ireland 🇮🇪
It’s great to see more and more Conservatives and Nationalists increasingly embrace Libertarianism here.
Libertarianism offers a philosophical and economic framework to shrink the state and empower the individual: that is its essence.
Its foundational principle, the sanctity of property rights, doubles as the bedrock of sound economics, also.
Everything flows from this: politically, it maximizes individual freedom, for more conservative types, and truly protects minorities, for more progressives types.
Libertarianism should, and can be, a bipartisan philosophy.
Economically, it enables optimal wealth creation, and preservation, and cuts the wasteful state. More growth, innovation, and jobs, and less reliance on government.
Irish critiques of Libertarianism and free markets often miss this foundational principle of property rights and self-agency.
Some argue Nationalism - a love for one’s nation - can’t work in a Libertarian framework, claiming that, for some reason, people wouldn’t feel this sense of patriotism without top-down state enforcement.
Not only does this make no sense, but it is ahistorical when it comes to the type of patriotism a nation should seek; a bottoms up spontaneous patriotism will always outlast a top down enforced one, ie the American, French or even Irish revolutions, versus the Soviet, Nazi, or Italian statist-kind.
Free people don’t need a boot on their neck to love their homeland.
In fact, it is the current state that has eroded that love over the passed few decades.
Libertarianism doesn’t dictate morality or culture; it leaves that to individuals and families, as it should be. If you want to impose your own version of morality on others, it’s not for you.
On economics, then, people argue that a free market is what has lead to a lot of Ireland's woes, while ignoring the huge growth that our openness to markets has allowed.
Here, the misstep is to equate EU globalisation, with free markets, which is to again forget the initial Libertarian principal of property rights, and self agency.
For example, our ability to provide a better interest rate to corporations was a huge economic incentive for businesses to come here.
Global trade agreements, including the growth strangling regulations that come with them, stifle this ability, greatly.
On the economics piece also, to think about Libertarian economics is to not just view one reductionist area of trade, it is to view it holistically.
If you think that a particular policy is negative for a certain industry, you must ask yourself what things look like when the same industry, and entire nations economy, also look like the following;
No taxation, workers get to keep 100% of their income, and businesses have far more to reinvest for growth, and a far greater margin for error when negotiating trade deals elsewhere.
It would be a completely new paradigm.
It would just be one without the pedaling middlemen of the state extracting wealth from everyone.
Immigration is another issue sometimes highlighted, but this is also among the easiest to solve for, imo.
If property rights are sacrosanct, and everything is privatised, then there isn't one hard border, there are thousands of even harder, smaller ones, with nobody having the right to encroach upon them without permission.
In a country 75-80% against the states ridiculous immigration position, this is solved for, immediately.
Remember, also, there is no welfare in such a society, removing a huge pull factor for negative immigration.
Every philosophy has trade-offs, but Irish objections to Libertarianism often miss the mark, imo.
We also have the entire 1,000 year Brehon period - our own unique period of self governance which also consisted of no top down state control, no monopoly on violence, on law, or on currency, as a similar example.
Rooted in individual rights and agency, Libertarianism is an antidote to authoritarianism, and a real economic alternative.
Being the party of sound money, property rights, the working class, and SMEs, also has some ring to it 🤝