We as a culture have lost all ability to maintain **fuzzy and slightly shifting but still very real** social boundaries. As a result, we end up with only two choices: Total free-for-all or draconian absolutely defined rule with OTT enforcement. Every behavior must be either applauded or viciously repressed. There is no room anymore for that very sane and useful cultural middle ground of “this gets some side-eye and social distance, but not a full-on attack mob”
1. Shameful things may be shameful, but shaming people for shameful things is bad (i.e. shameful)
2. When shaming becomes shameful, people shame much less (the desired result)
3. When shaming becomes much reduced, shameful behavior explodes, because there's nothing preventing it (the unintended consequence)
4. We should never, as a culture, have attempted to make shaming shameful. Shameful things ought to be shamed, even if it's "mean." Shaming ought not to be regarded as shameful cruelty, but as praiseworthy maintenance of civilizational standards