The Tale of Two Arab Journalists: At a diplomatic reception next to the United Nations, I was chatting with the deputy head of a UN delegation from a major nation in the Middle East about direct as well as cagey support for Hamas and its narratives, particularly outside of Gaza. A prominent Arab American journalist with whom I’m friendly walked by, and we conversed briefly with the deputy head of the delegation, after which the journalist asked me point-blank in a challenging tone: “Name one person who still supports Hamas.” I started talking about university students, elements of the “pro-Palestine” community, and influencers who play verbal gymnastics or express outright support for the terror group, to which he answered, “They don’t matter.”
Perhaps he meant that in a diplomatic context, no serious Arab or Western officials support Hamas, though I kept pushing back that public support for the group as part of the narrative and information warfare has a direct and linear impact on what diplomats and politicians can do and say. The gentleman also tried to argue that most Palestinians, including in Gaza, support the concept of the “resistance” which Hamas represents, something I immediately challenged as an out-of-date notion that is entirely divorced from what people in Gaza are thinking and saying about Hamas and the resistance narrative it has promulgated for decades. Soon after, he walked away.
In a beautiful, ironic twist, and almost immediately, a famous Arab journalist from the Middle East who knows me well came by and jokingly said, “I see you’re still talking about Hamas!” Hilariously, the same deputy head of the delegation with whom I was chatting asked this Arab journalist, “Does anyone still support Hamas?” to which he immediately answered, “Almost everybody outside of Gaza still does.” He said that the Arab public supports Hamas’s narratives, which in turn creates problems for Arab governments and diplomats. He also cited direct or indirect support for the terror group in diaspora Arab communities in the West, not to mention among a rising generation of non-Arabs in academia, politics, journalism, and NGOs.
This is exactly what I have been talking about for years: the disconnect between how the discourse is unfolding inside Gaza, and how it is registering for those in the diaspora communities with regard to their understanding of Palestinians in Gaza. Despite being loathed by Gazans for what it has done to them, Hamas has gone mainstream and been normalized in a horrific manner. Many Arab Americans, including Palestinian and Muslim Americans, unfortunately live in bubbles and don’t care to learn detailed, nuanced information about how much they’ve become players in a narrative warfare which is deeply harmful and destructive to the Palestinian people.
The aforementioned interaction was the perfect representation of two intelligent Arab journalists looking at the same issue fundamentally differently, because one wants to make a point as part of a narrative, while the other wants to make a difference as part of self-critique and a push for evolution that impacts policy and diplomacy.