I keep going back to Covenant College because it is associated with my denomination and emblematic of the missed opportunity.
Covenant comes from the Reformed tradition—the same one that produced Harvard, Yale, Princeton, etc—and is associated with the PCA, the most prominent evangelical denomination in this tradition. Yet Covenant is objectively academically mediocre and not a draw to most of the best students from even the PCA (students who want a liberal arts education). It has a few “conservative” professors (again, more of the David French variety), but its center of gravity is closer to Russell Moore (whom it recently hosted for a flagship lecture), and some are clear left-wing activists.
Covenant is not a serious competitor to eg Davidson College, which is also traditionally Presbyterian (albeit with the more liberal PCUSA) and in the same region, but academically elite. Davidson is older and richer, but Covenant doesn’t even try to compete on the vectors that could give it an advantage, especially an intentional divergence from mainstream academic leftism and robust exploration of alternatives that build on the Reformed tradition.
If Covenant did this, it might become a magnet for top Reformed (and broadly evangelical) students and academics who could choose elite schools but are put off by the pervasive leftism of mainstream academia. It could quickly become a center of compelling Reformed thought across academic disciplines—a successor of sorts of elite universities that were built on but abandoned this tradition. Far from requiring compromise of Covenant’s Reformed identity, this would follow a doubling down on the distinctives of the Reformed academic tradition.
But instead Covenant has accepted a path that is generically evangelical, academically complacent, and actively averse to many of the cultural and political trends that could actually draw people to it. This pattern is far too common among Christian colleges, and the missed opportunity is a real tragedy—for Christian students and academics, for the growing political right (which would benefit from stronger Christian influence), and for America.