Protecting Students or Teachers
The NYC mayor and schools chancellor announced a total ban on the use of student facing AI to keep doing what works. What works? There has been a massive drop in nyc student reading scores.
This is not a ban on students using AI in their homes — it is a ban on using AI tutors and programs to help students learn. It’s obvious that personalized AI tutors could be a huge boon to education in New York where many schools are failing. But for now that’s not for NYC students.
And their fate will be determined by a committee that includes, according to the official nyc press release, “students, educators, parent leaders, elected officials, advocates, union partners and experts in the field.” So experts are an afterthought while “union partners” are on it to protect the unions and their power which would obviously be eroded by the success of AI tutoring and teaching.
So quick headline readers think this is great — kids will be learning and not using AI. No, they will still be using AI at home. They and their teachers will be blocked, however, from learning with tailored AI learning programs that can revolutionize learning. When you actually read that the future of NYC’s kids are turned over to a union-infused commissariat-like committee you see kids being held back for a very different agenda.