“100 percent politically homeless.”
As Election Day 2026 draws near, the stakes for many Americans seem higher than in previous midterms. Will Democrats get their blue wave, or will voters hand Republicans and President Trump sufficient victories to retain the House or Senate—or both? Will the advent of more and more Democratic Socialists into the arena spell doom for Democratic hopes? Will American voters’ concerns about the cost of living, attacks on voting rights, or growing distaste for giving aid to Israel tilt midterm races in one direction or another? And among Jewish voters, how many are driven by the proverbial question: Will it (the election) be good for the Jews?
As we have in previous election years, Moment’s Jewish Political Voices Project (JPVP) team has carefully selected a small cross section of voters from all walks of Jewish life in America. JPVP’s unique methodology is to closely follow the thinking of these voters in the months before and after a national election, allowing Moment readers to connect with real people in real Jewish communities who are wrestling with political decisions in real time. Over the years, we’ve found that this process yields far more illuminating information than the anonymous snapshots that emerge from polls.
This year, the voters we are following come from small enclaves like Readfield, Maine, and bigger ones like Brooklyn, New York, and Dallas, Texas. Among them, we have an epidemiologist, two lawyers, a school nurse, a college senior and a residential property manager. They vary widely in terms of political ideology, age and Jewish denomination and practice.
Two things stand out in this year’s JPVP compared to the past: People are much more emotional in their responses, and more of them are affiliating with Independents and describing themselves as troubled by the two major parties. Jewish voters are hardly alone in feeling alienated; in a New York Times/Siena poll of American voters conducted in May, 43 percent said they’re dissatisfied with both parties. For JPVP voters who express feeling “politically homeless,” Israel and concerns about antisemitism seem to be the main drivers.
Discover America’s Jewish voters, in their own voices, by reading the cover story of our latest issue.
momentmag.com/fall-2026/