This is not good enough.
Sarah Steele was strangled and allegedly sexually assaulted by Jacob Wulfson, a US pilot then based at Lakenheath.
Wulfson was tried in a US military court by a jury of fellow officers. He should have faced the English courts, but the police handed the case to the Americans.
The NATO Status of Forces Agreement makes clear that the US military only has jurisdiction when an offence is committed on duty, against another member of the same armed forces or against a dependant.
As the local MP and Shadow Justice Secretary, I wrote to David Lammy and then his successor, Alex Norris, about how the police and prosecutors handle these cases.
Since then, other victims have contacted me. More recently, a US diplomat, allegedly a paedophile, was flown out of London to avoid prosecution here.
This letter is the Justice Secretary’s reply.
I asked who relinquished sovereignty in Sarah’s case. Norris said decisions on jurisdiction are a matter for the relevant police force. That may be so, but we still need to know who made the decision so there can be accountability and change. He refuses to say.
I asked for an update on discussions with the US Government. He confirmed they are taking place but provided no detail.
I asked what processes ensure crimes committed by base personnel are reported and prosecuted in England. Again, there was no real answer, only an assertion that the Government will “identify and learn lessons” from Sarah’s case, and confirmation that chief constables have been contacted.
I asked the Ministry of Justice to review every case I have raised. Despite this concerning jurisdiction and justice in our own country, I was merely told my letter would be passed to the Foreign Office.
In all, this reply is really not acceptable.
It fails to address the main issues head-on. These cases clearly conflict with what is supposed to happen under the framework of the NATO Status of Forces Agreement 1951, and CPS guidance.
The Justice Secretary failed to address this point, and just reiterated that there are “limited circumstances” where jurisdiction should be transferred.