The Mets didn’t have a “terrible” farm at the time whatsoever. Baseball America ranked them 8th, ESPN ranked them 11 and 13 by MLB Pipeline. Above average rank by all the experts at the time.
What exactly do McLean, Scott, Ewing and Soto have to do with Stearns? None were brought in by him and Soto was all Cohen. Bichette hasn’t made any impact on this team and Lindor also has zero to do with Stearns. And now the farm is ranked less than the end of 2023 / start of 2024 time you’re referencing. Terrible points.
Starting pitching was definitely not a strength then but Scott and McLean were still developing during the time you’re mentioning. Even now, outside of McLean, nobody has proven nearly enough yet even though Scott and Thornton have looked good this year. It’s not like anyone thinks the Mets have a championship worthy rotation at this moment, and Stearns has failed to build a rotation with Major League acquisitions the last 2 years.
If you’re spending $300-400M and can only be confident with about 7 players on the roster heading into 2027 and one of those may not even be here, you’re clearly just coping. This is MLB, not the NBA. Filling about 15 roster spots is impossible in 1 year, especially for a guy who couldn’t handle about 5. Stearns has objectively been one of the biggest failures in baseball history. Nobody else in MLB history has spent nearly this much to miss the playoffs in-back-to-back years. Defending it is outrageous enough, using an argument where most of the players referenced had nothing to do with Stearns is even dumber.
When David Stearns took over in 2024, the core was:
29-year-old Pete Alonso
30-year-old Francisco Lindor
30-year-old Edwin Díaz
31-year-old Brandon Nimmo
32-year-old Jeff McNeil
The Mets had a terrible farm and an organization that couldn’t develop anyone. There wasn’t even a single starting pitcher in that core.
In 2026, less than three full seasons later, that core is now:
21-year-old A.J. Ewing
23-year-old Carson Benge
24-year-old Nolan McLean
27-year-old Christian Scott
27-year-old Juan Soto
28-year-old Bo Bichette
32-year-old Francisco Lindor
Other than Lindor, the oldest guy in that group is 28. The youngest is 21. When Stearns took over the youngest in that group was 29 years old! Now the organization can actually develop players and has one of the better farm systems in baseball.
Stearns reset a core that made the playoffs twice in six years — ONCE UNDER HIM! Alonso, Nimmo, and McNeil were not even why the Mets made the playoffs in 2024. Instead they were a big reason that team was fighting until the very last day of the season to clinch. Lindor along with the players Stearns put around them carried that team into the playoffs while those other guys all had down years.
Yet fans will still tell you Stearns has done an awful job. Almost every other team in baseball would take him tomorrow. Claiming he has run the Mets into the ground and that he’s a total disaster is dishonest and irrational. Thinking he hasn’t built this roster to be a future consistent contender just means you’re not watching or you’re out of touch. It’s egregious.
Missing the playoffs one year into a core reset is not some unprecedented disaster. Especially when most of the team’s core was either hurt or in the minors during this season other than Bichette, McLean, and Benge. Missing the playoffs happens to a lot of teams when they move on and stop running it back with a stale, aging group and actually start focusing on their future building the next core.
The other option was keeping a group that was only getting older and punting the future. That tradeoff makes no sense. This is the most realistic way to build a World Series contender. Especially one that can compete year after year.
#LGM