To be very clear, I’m very much in favor of major NATO reforms, specifically on member nations & spending. NATO as is has flaws, but the logic & strategic importance is still viable nonetheless. With that said, the case to be made as to why our current reaction to European NATO countries in regard to the Iran conflict is shortsighted & counterintuitive to our interests isn’t hard to make.
The case:
Last year President Trump rightfully made it clear that it’s time for the European NATO nations to take the lead on all aspects of defense in relation to Europe. He stated that the U.S. will no longer prioritize Europe’s defense, that we’ll be focused on our interests & our hemisphere & not being the collective defense of everyone else. There wasn’t anyone on our side of the political aisle that didn’t agree with the logic, we would focus on our backyard & Europe would focus on theirs, the alliance would thrive as a whole when the individual parts all thrived independently.
We’re now roughly 12 months from when those statements were made, & we’re again carrying out operations in the Middle East which as you may know is not in our hemisphere. Don’t get me wrong, I’m in support of taking out the Iranian regime, destroying their pursuit of nuclear weapons, stopping the funding of terrorism, & the general issues they cause. It’s how we went about it & how we’re reacting that I think is ridiculous. There’s plenty of cases to be made as to why Iran posed a credible threat, I personally don’t think any of them were imminent by definition tho. President Trump decided to not make a case to NATO, he absolutely could have used Article 4 which applies to security threats in any part of the world, including territories overseas & **consulted** with NATO countries. He didn’t for reasons I’m sure he had & that’s fine, but in doing so he made it OUR play, a play we’re not alone in since Israel & the Gulf Nations are involved.
Let’s be clear:
-It was our choice to engage Iran
-It was our choice to not include NATO
-It was our choice to tell European NATO countries to focus & prioritize Europe’s defense.
We didn’t bring them to the party, & now we’re acting outraged because they don’t want to dance. WE told them to focus on Europe’s defense, WE told them that they had to prioritize their backyards, & now that they are we’re acting baffled. We can’t float the excuse that “Iran posses a threat to Europe too” since we didn’t think it was enough of a threat to bring them in from the start, it was our choice. Again, there’s issues with NATO members, it’s not perfect, & some of the petty responses are painfully stupid, but they shouldn’t matter. We shouldn’t want them involved, they’re doing what we said they should & by trying to force them into this fight will just cause them to deplete their stocks of munitions, they’ll no longer buy weapons for Ukraine which will benefit Russia, & it will place them right back under our defense umbrella. No one benefits from Iran’s regime being dismantled & the SOH open more than Israel & the Gulf states, the incredibly wealthy Gulf States. Instead of crying that NATO is doing as we asked, we should be portraying our strength on our Gulf allies to step up. It’s insane how willing we are to big brother European NATO countries, but not the Gulf ones. The Gulf states don’t have the physical resources to go about it on their own, but they do have the financial ones & they could bankroll us for our services. They could replenish our stocks, they can buy more weapons, they could take a bigger role in the conflict that’s IN THEIR BACKYARD. We told Europe to focus on their backyard, & they’re doing so. We said that we were going to focus on our backyard, & we kinda did & are, but for some reason we’re unwilling to tell our Gulf allies that it’s time they focus on theirs.