Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas denied 78% of homeowner claims last year.
That's not a typo.
Weiss Ratings analyzed 2025 data across the industry. Here's what they found:
Mid-Century Insurance of Texas: 78% closed without payment.
Lemonade Insurance: 64%.
Citizens Property Insurance: 61%.
Spinnaker Insurance: 61%.
Across the 15 largest insurers studied, more than half of all homeowner claims were closed with zero payout.
Nationally, 42% of all homeowner claims from all carriers ended the same way.
A decade ago, the five largest insurance groups - Allstate, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, State Farm, USAA - didn't pay on 36% of claims. Last year, that number crossed 44%.
These aren't edge cases. This is the business model.
When an insurer closes nearly 8 out of 10 claims without payment, the process is designed to find reasons to deny — and it's working.
If you've received a denial, don't accept it as final. Get an independent assessment. Review your policy language.
The numbers say your insurer's first answer is increasingly likely to be no.