My quibble about including Sopranos and West Wing aside,
I’ve come to believe Mad Men should be number 1 on the NYT list.
All of the top 10 are brilliant and masterfully conceived and beautifully shot and perfectly acted and so dramatic and authentic and funny when needed but Mad Men had one more thing: the burden of history. JFK, moon landing, the coke commercial, the suits, the dresses, the first time someone from the east went on a plane to go to LA - all had to stand up to a perfect memory of it. And they Beamoned it.
(Soap is a human essential and opera is high art and my ancestral pride)
Mad Men confuses me. I don't get how so many adult males got tricked into watching a soap opera.