Visa vs Mastercard looks like a coin toss. Until you zoom out.
Over the 5 years through September 18, 2026, with dividends reinvested,
$MA returned 11.16% annually.
$V returned 11.52%.
Pretty close. Now extend that same comparison to TEN years.
Mastercard: 19.69% annually. Visa: 17.02%.
That turned the same $10,000 investment into roughly $60,300 with Mastercard versus $48,200 with Visa.
Both made patient shareholders serious money. But calling them interchangeable misses how much a few percentage points can add up.
I like businesses like these. I’m still going to care what I pay for them, because those historical returns aren’t a promise about the next decade.