Personal update: today my time at @OilersNation comes to an end. Was my choice and it was very tough. I owe a lot to @zjlaing and @jsbmbaggedmilk who gave me a chance and guided me along the way. The people at ON are passionate about their craft and I’ll miss that.
1/2
Howard best player for Oilers.
Cibulka best D.
Samanski getting stronger as camp comes to an end.
Quinn Hutson with his best game.
Quality effort by the whole group.
David kindly allowed me to QP. David is correct: Messier has a right to an opinion. He doesn't even have to earn it as we are all entitled.
He definitely won a SC for NYR.
To say he is horrified about the situation is unfair since he did the same thing at least twice.
1/2
Please explain what you mean? As far as NY is concerned, the guy literally put the team on his back to win a cup. 1 of 6 rings he has. I think he’s earned the right to have an opinion
Whether he's right/wrong on the topic isn't my issue. He should have provided context saying "I've done this and.." He didn't. If he can offer that commentary/context, I'll listen. Without that, to me only, it's not a good look from one of my favs.
Thx David for the post.
2/2
A note on my publishing. I will be writing on Sunday at Substack about each prospect in camp, what I saw during pre-season and what needs to happen going forward.
On Tuesday I'll have a post on Oiler team tactics I noticed with the new staff in each zone and specialty teams.
I’m sorry. I love Mark Messier and what he did for the Oilers. However his time in NY and Vancouver and what he demanded make his comments today troubling to me.
The quandary with this description of Dach is that you don’t want a C doing a bunch of what he’s seeing routinely. That’s a W role.
If that’s the messaging I think the ask is too high and potentially quite confusing. Dach’s success the other night was a combo of reasons.
1/3
Coach Babcock spoke with the media following practice about the #Oilers first preseason game, the effort on the ice today & playing McDavid with Draisaitl.
1. They played the Manitoba Moose.
2. His wingers crushed it on the forecheck. These are NHL wingers so no surprise at all.
3. His wingers played a strong DZ wall game.
4. This allowed Dach to played low in DZ and hit guys with abandon to separate them from pucks.
2/3
I love this trial with Dach at C. I worry about puck skills against an NHL roster. Especially one that will line match hard.
I think the Oil will miss his F1 ability to punish defenders. Others will have to step up.
That said if he can make it, big win all around.
3/3
One thing I would be cautious about is evaluating a player absent context. Ike Howard is not a play driver. Ideally he’s a “catch and shoot” player using basketball parlance. He can get a puck. Give it up. Get to a spot. Get it back. Shoot it. He’s the finisher.
1/4
But remember he got to those spots. There are players on this team who will see him. If that happens and he scores, does that change the analysis?
On the flip side, Josh Samanski. He was put in a role tonight where he should succeed. He struggled. A lot. That’s a concern.
3/4
Both of these players will likely end up in the AHL caveat injuries. Nothing wrong with that. Development is not a straight line.
Both have NHL futures. Soon. Just be cautious about evaluating them similarly without applying context.
4/4
I really don’t think you can take much from the pre-season game against the Manitoba Moose. However given the new training camp rules, you probably can make a fairly accurate guess after game 2 on Tuesday of what the opening night roster will be. The caveat being injuries.