The Myth of an Islamic Reformation
On October 31, 1517 German Catholic Priest, Martin Luther, nailed a list of 95 Theses (or arguments) against the Catholic Church to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany.
This sparked the beginning of the Protestant Reformation, leading to major changes to the Christian Church at large, and to the culture of Europe as we know it. Indeed, you can trace the cultural roots of the United States to the Protestant Reformation. There is no doubt that without it the world would be a very different place, and not for the better.
Recently I have heard several folks refer to a hypothetical "Islamic Reformation," suggesting that such a thing ought to take place, or even that it will take place, it's just a matter of time.
The argument goes that Islam is "due" a reformation. After all, such a thing happened about 1,500 years into the Christian faith, and we're getting close to that with Islam, so why not?
I'll tell you why not.
1) I think the underlying premise here is wrong. If you look at religion through a secular, "neutral," sociological lens, you might believe that you can simply rearrange the pieces of any given religion like building blocks and make a new structure entirely, but it's not that simple.
Religions are not interchangeable, and Christianity and Islam are fundamentally different from one another across a host of important metrics. In fact, Islam is fundamentally different from all religions across a host of metrics, but we'll stick to the Christian-Islamic comparison for now.
Christianity is, at its core, about the worship of the one true God, and having a right relationship with him, achievable exclusively by Grace, through Faith in His Son, Jesus. Christianity is Trinitarian, meaning we believe in One God in Three Persons (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). Christianity fully affirms the Old Testament, aka the Hebrew Bible aka The Tanakh, but it doesn't stop there. The New Testament of the Christian Bible explicitly quotes the Old Testament between 280 and 350 times, and alludes to the Old Testament over 1,000 times. Christianity is authentically the continuation of something, rather than something entirely new, Christians today read the Old Testament as much as the New.
By contrast, Islam is a religion that is fundamentally about submission (to the will of Allah, as described by his Muhammad), and his will is... conquest. The official founding of Islam occurred with the founding of an Islamic State, and it's growth has occurred through the growth of that state as driven by military conquest. This is both what Islam's holy book (the Quran) has prescribed, and it is what Muslims have done for 1,400 years. While the Quran states that both the Old and New Testaments of the Bible are true, it quotes the Bible a grand total of ZERO times. Rather, it twists the narrative of scripture, or downright contradicts it in almost every place that it does refer to the Bible, and Muslims almost never read the Bible unless they're involved professionally in apologetics against Christianity.
2) The Protestant Reformation, amongst other things, was about a return to scripture. One of the major components of the Reformation was Sola Scriptura, or "Scripture Alone." Over time, the Catholic Church had drifted away from relying heavily on the Bible, and instead more heavily upon the teachings of the Pope and other Church leaders. When those teachings were not supported by the Bible, or worst, contradicted the Bible, it simply wasn't seen as a big deal, and since there was so little emphasis on the Bible anyway, most folks didn't know the Bible well enough to even notice such contradictions.
Christian Reformation inherently meant becoming more devout according to the original texts, not some new "version" of Christianity that was "updated" for more a more modern era. And what does a devout Christian look like? What does an "extreme" Christian look like? It looks like someone who loves God and loves their neighbor. It looks like someone who is willing to lay down his own life for others. It looks like a person who speaks truth, and helps the poor. It looks like someone who forgives, even when forgiveness looks impossible.
A comparable "Reformation" within Islam would mean a return to the fundamental texts of Islam, aka the Quran, and what does the Quran say? Quran 9:5 commands Muslims to kill Christians wherever they find them, to capture them and besiege them, and to lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But they can be allowed to live if they repent, and establish prayer, and pay a special tax.
This is what devout Muslims believe. This is the law devout Muslims follow, which leads me to the 3rd, and final point:
3) A "Reformation" of Islam cannot, and will not happen, but what is happening instead is a cycle of devoutness to complacency to devoutness against that has been going on since the beginning of Islam in 622 AD.
The first 100 years of Islam was explosive. Part of Muhammad's teaching was not only that Muslims must engage in physical, violent battle and conquest against the Infidels, but that the result of said violence is win-win. If you live you get to keep the spoils of war that you capture, including slaves, and especially female slaves, who you can do whatever you want with sexually (this is in the Quran) with no consequences whatsoever. And guess what! If you die, even better! You go to paradise where you will have 72 perpetual virgins who please you sexually all the time, and they're even described as having large eyes and large breasts. Yes, they're essentially anime characters.
These incentives worked well, and Islam went from being present in one city in the desert of what is now Saudi Arabia, to conquering all of what we now know as the Middle East and North Africa, and virtually all of Spain in less than 100 years.
But in 718 they failed in their Siege of Constantinople, and in 732 they were stopped from conquering France by Charles "The Hammer" Martel at the Battle of Tours. Their growth, for the time being, was stopped. Islamic warlords who had amassed insane wealth began to think more about how they could maintain their wealth and standards of living, and focused less on expansionary Jihad, and more on enjoying life and protecting what they had. So began an era of complacency.
But eras of complacency were always temporary.
There were always underdogs, who read the Quran, and hated the hypocrisy, opulence, and laziness of their leaders. With their devotion they would inspire a following of those who were also devout, and also ready to risk their lives in a fight. The devout would take over, supplanting the complacent leadership, and leading new rounds of Jihad and conquest.
The cycle continued for hundreds of years. In that time Islam has had upswings and downswings. In 1683 they besieged Vienna Austria, on the edge of taking all of Europe, but they were thankfully defeated. Thus began a several-hundred-year downward spiral.
In the present day we've forgotten what a threat Islam once was to the West, but we're starting to remember.
6% of the UK is Muslim. 10% of France is Muslim. Austria is 8% Muslim. Netherlands is 7% Muslim.
You see it in the riots in France. You see it in the rape gangs in the UK. You see terrorist training camps in Amsterdam.
Even the US faces a massive growth in mosques and Islamic communities practicing Shariah (Islamic Law) rather than American Law. Whole neighborhoods are popping up with Arabic street names and HOA dues that fund the local mosques. In the USA.
Do not expect an Islamic Reformation, because there won't be one.
What will happen is that the moderate Muslims will continue to lose influence and market share across the globe as Islam grows, and all Muslims see that they have the opportunity to have an upper hand over the Infidels.
All Muslims, even if they claim to be moderate, know what the Quran commands about conquest, about killing Infidels, about forcing Infidels to submit to Islam. Any Muslim who remains Muslim is choosing Islam over every other system, and they will not stick their necks out for the Infidels when faced with a choice.
It's high time that the West in general, and America in particular wake up to what Islam is. Enough wishful thinking. The history of Islam is long, and it is brutal, and we are absolute fools if we believe that it will ever stop of its own accord. Muslims explicitly believe that they can and must lie to Infidels, even in official matters such as treaties. Historically peace has existed between Muslims and Christians, but it was always temporary, and served as an opportunity for Muslims to regain their footing before betraying Christians and attacking again.
Let's learn from the past, and use what we have learned to secure our future.
SOLI DEO GLORIA
PAX AMERICANA 🇺🇸