Does anyone else feel like the fear machine is running at full volume again.
AI WILL TAKE OVER!!!
It will become superintelligent. It will decide humans are surplus, cue the breathless TV news segments.
I don’t buy the sudden-extinction story. Not because I think the technology is harmless, but because I think the more plausible damage is slower, quieter, and already underway.
The real risk is not Skynet. It is cognitive offloading at population scale.
We are handing over the work that used to build judgment: drafting, comparing sources, holding an argument in working memory, noticing when something doesn’t add up. The research is already coming out.
Michael Gerlich’s 2025 study of 666 people found a clear negative relationship between frequent AI tool use and critical thinking scores.
It's called cognitive offloading. When you delegate the hard mental work to the model. Younger users (17–25) showed the highest reliance and the weakest scores. Education helped, but only when people still did the thinking themselves.
Students test scores drop by 17%. They look more productive. They have learned less.
MIT researchers shows people write essays with ChatGPT found lower neural connectivity and weaker recall of their own text.
A 2026 review in Trends in Cognitive Sciences put it cleanly: learned skills atrophy when we offload them. Writing, analysis, diagnosis, design all suffer when we stop practising.
This is the slow death, not the robot war.
We are creating a generation that can generate a polished answer without being able to defend it.
Act2 is worse.
Cory Doctorow’s enshittification pattern is already visible in search, social feeds, and marketplaces: first delight users, then lock them in, then extract.
LLMs are next.
Ads are arriving, sponsored “suggestions.”, affiliate-shaped recommendations. We all know the goal is to sell attention rather than give the best answer, the model’s voice will stop being a tool and start being a channel. Political framing, commercial nudges, and social steering are all on the table and worse.
When you no longer generate the first draft of your own thinking, you are easier to steer.
None of this requires rouge AGI taking over it requires bad habits.
I am not saying be a Luddite, but I am warning about becoming a drone.
Models are not a substitute for a prefrontal cortex. Use them as a sparing partner. Demand sources. Keep some work deliberately unaided so the muscle does not atrophy.
The civilisation-ending story makes for great click bait, but the land where people cannot think without a prompt window, and prompt windows that increasingly think for someone else’s P&L is the one we should actually worry about.