What if there were calls for widespread protests in support of the 9/11 hijackers, three years after 3,000 Americans were murdered? What if tens of thousands rallied for the Nazis on the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz?
No one would need to be told how obscene that was.
Yet here is a flyer for a "citywide protest" at New York's City Hall on October 7, three years to the day after the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust. It promises "glory to the martyrs, victory to the resistance."
And there are dozens of rallies planned across America and European cities and campuses.
Pick that date, put a masked figure at the center of the poster, and promise victory to "the resistance," and you've told everyone whose side you are on.
What they are celebrating is not hard to reconstruct.
On October 7, Hamas terrorists went house to house in the kibbutzim. They broke into safe rooms and set homes on fire to drive families out. Infants, children, and people in their 80s and 90s were killed in their beds and in their safe rooms. At the Nova festival, they hunted people across open fields for hours, shot those hiding in bomb shelters and under vehicles, raped and mutilated, and took captives.
After 9/11, America said you are either with us or against us. The line seemed clear. You stood for the West and what it represents, or you stood with a nihilistic religious extremism that wanted to replace it with a medieval theocracy.
That line has been blurred by a generation raised on an oppressor/oppressed script, by Gulf money flowing into our universities, and by a media and political class that has decided criticizing the killers, the extremists, the Islamists, is somehow intolerant.
So tomorrow, neighbors, our students, people we work beside, will rally to honor the mass murder of that day.
I'm sorry if this sounds grim. For those of us commemorating the memory of the victims, it is a disgraceful inversion of fact and history.