"Crowded trades are only an X concept."
Yes, most likely, yes, I agree with this.
Actually, the problem is that you can never properly understand these kinds of myths or concepts. Because until you have an evidence to prove something or to establish the existence of something, you can neither deny it nor confirm it.
I think we fintwit traders mainly have a condition like that of a frog in a well, where we start treating that entire well as our world and don't really understand what exists outside it. 🐸
So we see ten traders posting the same charts and think, "Probably everyone is interested in this stock at this level." And then we assess that this stock, for this particular day or this particular entry level, is crowded.
But there is no way to measure how many of those traders posting the charts are actually taking the trade, or whether they have enough capital to actually influence the stock at that price. We are simply making an assessment based on the limited information available to us.
And what is a trader who isn't on X doing? He doesn't even look at all this. He's not there in that world. He's simply looking at a stock, seeing a setup, and saying, "There is a setup here, and I will enter at this level."
Now, he can imagine, "If I'm seeing this, other people must be seeing it too. And If everyone else is seeing it, maybe I shouldn't even attempt this setup because it's crowded."
And then he can take that one step further and say, "A lot of people will think that everyone is interested in this stock, so they won't enter because they think it's crowded. And the moment they don't enter because they think it's crowded, the stock becomes un-crowded again."
There is no end to such speculation. And I don't think this kind of thought process deserves any weight in a trading strategy.
So, are some trades actually crowded?
And if they are, does that have any impact on their outcome?
I don't think we will ever be able to understand this in scientific terms or in any concrete, evidence-based format, because the possibility of analyzing it in this way is very limited.
तो जिस चीज़ का कोई proof नहीं है, उसमें हमारा कोई interest नहीं है। हम नहीं मानते, हम नहीं जानते, हम नहीं समझते।
हम अपने दिमाग की limited capacity उन चीज़ों पर लगाना पसंद करेंगे जिनका evidence है और जिन्हें scientifically, logically और rationally समझा जा सकता है, बजाय उन concepts के जिन्हें prove या disprove ही नहीं किया जा सकता.
crowded trades is only an x concept I think 😭😭