But..... what happens when you add up Ninatrader + Tradovate + TradingView, which all use the same backend for their fills. Just curious. @MattLeech

Jul 24, 2025 · 10:18 PM UTC

36
93
24,288
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
haha, you vote Tradovate lol , funny , all people know project x not doing great
1
19
2,478
Ofcourse, it has the worse fills.
3
2
2,369
Why even pay @MattLeech any attention @projectxtrading is revolutionary nothing compares‼️
9
2,326
Maybe I'm not paying enough attn, but I've never noticed any issues with fills. Keep up the good work. You've built a great platform, and it's still quite new.
3
734
I trade on ProjectX and Tradovate daily. I see the difference in fills consistently and my findings lead me to believe that If im worried about milliseconds and even 4-6tivks worth of spread and entry point variance, and my strategy cant handle it, then im risking to much. Never bet on the platform, bet on yourself and play the game better than anyone. That's how you win
4
24
2,012
There’s a reason why majority of traders call it slipX lol
9
498
Topstepx is a great platform but needs bracket orders & I gotta say winning by 4% is pretty much a tie. Why not strive to be the best in all area's including fills?
5
737
That's a good point actually
1
1
1,262
People whining about fills, if you're a momentum trader you should expect slippage, if you're not, you should be using limit orders. Bad fills aren't the problem; bad trading is
1
3
383
So you're saying back end is the only factor behind bad fills? Nothing in between? No front end involvement? Imagine: a platform trying to steal from long standing platforms, while having a worse platform, and misrepresenting how the system works. You suck @projectxtrading
3
539
But here I am still waiting on topstep to dig into my issue I had a few days ago… lost 5 xfa with 7500 in profit because the DLL I had set never closed out the position. So much for “risk settings”
1
1
834
I had a profit target (limit order) that filled 4 points higher while using tradingview....which screwed me over because of the 20% consistency rule.
1
2
336
quantower baby
2
1,032
None of these are good platforms. Project x is definitely the closest but it just moves so slow.
1
1,470
I cant confirm this poll tbh...never had any issues with projectx
1
609
You mean SnitchX
171
Don’t take it too hard @projectxtrading most are just reviewing based off nostalgia/ old bias this competition is healthy for everyone
115
The hate is crazy. ProjectX is where its at.
256
Please fix your charts. They are so buggy. Have a real day trader sit down with one of you coders to explain all the issues this platform is having.
98
Sure, you have innovation. But every other day the errors keep happening.
1
165
i really dont think there is any difference
1
557
Project X is gold comparing to ninja, ctrader, tradovate. They're all far behind in terms of innovation, simplicity and good looking. It ain't 2001 anymore.
1
2
342
The front end is the issue. Slow refresh rate and lag. That's why TV is second place.
1
318
If I execute on Tradngview using Tradeovate credentials, fills and slippagge are insane. Same is not the issue when using CUG data feed on AMP
1
280
Hey @projectxtrading How come when copy trading multiple accounts on ProjectX I get different fills on each account, but the same exact fills when copy trading directly on Tradovate?
1
402
Projectx not playing games. They even blocked serial blocker Matt, who got butt hurt for getting blocked and gets easily butt hurt that he blocks everyone that doesn’t agree with him.
1
1
67
When will @projectxtrading enable risk forecasting prior to entering the trade. I want to set a limit order, and a SL and adjust my risk/lot size prior to sending the order.
46
Does your support ever get back to tickets? I had an api question but still no reply.
282
Project X needs to add order flow tools, until then is just a tradingview with an improved dom l
285
Show us the code for getting filled. Clearly the logic is wrong.
789
ProjectX and TradingView.
385
If there is a risk calculator for each specific contract built in that will be great.
532
fucking schwab commissions both ways
1
50