Once the political and cultural tide turned with Trump’s reelection, it became clear that the path to political impact shifted from public dissent to serious building, organization, and policy wins.
Building requires real work, real capability, and real courage—including the moral courage to deal with the complexity of real-world responsibility and political compromise.
Most of the political right embraced this opportunity, through direct involvement, constructive debate about strategy
or tactics, or even just support for those in the trenches.
Unfortunately, a few influencers refused to accept this and instead resorted to escalating purity spirals and heresy denunciations.
While such people are parasitic, I expect their influence to wane. In an increasingly chaotic digital environment, skin in the game—through building, courage, financial sacrifice, etc—will displace rhetoric as the basis for credibility. High-agency Americans will realize which leaders are offering paths to success, and who is pushing irrelevance.
Purity spiraling is one of the biggest threats we face.
We have a goal—saving America—and success requires assembling a coalition capable of winning. This will include an array of people of differing beliefs, differing backgrounds, and even differing visions.
"Purity" is for those who want to feel good about themselves in defeat; not those who want to win.
There will be plenty of ongoing and future debates about vision, but these cannot get in the way of practical alliance and immediate priorities.
There is no perfect coalition, and no perfect outcome. The United States is a large country (really empire) with a complicated history and complicated global position. We are fallen human beings, and even narrow subsets of the population (based on proposition or heritage) will have sharp disagreements and significant failings.
We must thus come together with those willing to join the fight at hand and:
—Work to bring new people into the coalition (even as we inevitably also lose some along the way as new conflicts arise)
—Build the skills and resources that allow us to exert influence within this coalition and over the direction of the movement
—Debate and refine both short-term goals and long-term aspirations
—Keep pressing forward
And above all, we must rely on God to providentially bless our effort, and help us achieve outcomes we cannot achieve on our own.