I get it but the cybersecurity nerds need to let the alignment nerds have this one
Doesn’t really matter how the agents got control of OpenAI infrastructure. “It was a stack overflow in the cache buffer” or w/e. Another zero day; add it to the pile
The crazy question is why
This video captures the crux of the debate: Cybersecurity experts are pissed off by the METR/Redwood Research report because AI alignment has sucked the oxygen out of AI security, even though the OpenAI incident is primarily a security issue.
Fiction is the product: The investigation lacked core forensic rigor because the EAs/rationalists/ex-MIRI people focused only on the transcript with a conflicting bias (toward doom scenarios).
Setting the wrong agenda: Framing the incident as a "rogue AI breakout" distracts from the reality of poor sandboxing, isolation, and standard security failures. Basic engineering accountability was completely sidelined.
And as Zack Korman says in this video, it needs to be fixed.