One of the many problems with Civic Nationalism is that, to be taken seriously as a movement, it must treat those who do not share the civics as essentially enemies or traitors to the nation.
That's relatively easy to do for some people. Hasan Piker should not spend another second trampling the soil of my country. He unquestionably should be deported.
But if America is simply an idea, how do you protect that idea perpetually? Ask yourself if you know anyone in your own family who has been ideologically captured by Wokeism. Are you going to support denaturalizing your own flesh and blood? Your own parents, siblings, or children?
The problem is that enormous chunks of our own people have been indoctrinated into Progressivism to the point where they fundamentally reject the idea that Civic Nationalists claim America stands for. But that doesn't change the fact that our loved ones are still Americans.
The solution here is that instead of deporting your own siblings because they've been captured by the Progressive omnicause, we should enact cultural and immigration reforms that enable a perpetual Right-wing majority and deprive the Left of its political power.
Ancestral Americans naturally produce a particular culture. A very vocal minority of Americans have become Leftists, but that minority is only able to wield power through education and immigration. They do not largely reproduce on their own but instead indoctrinate future generations of Americans into becoming Progressives, all while importing vast numbers of Third World socialists from abroad to shore up the Democratic Party's voting base.
If you wield state power to cut off the flow of new voters for the Left and crush their indoctrination networks in the media and academia, you can win this war without ever having to pit brother against sister, or father against son.
We actually have it in our power to save our own people from the Progressive omnicause, but it requires us to recognize that there is a people to save in the first place.
If it meant that all those who don't subscribe could be excluded, would you still oppose it?