In the interest of accountability, I got one fact wrong in my earlier post.
Canada did not experience net negative migration during the first half of 2026. I had seen today’s new Q2 figure before posting, but I had not yet yet caught the revisions to earlier quarters.
Technically, Canada has experienced very modest population growth YTD. That correction does not change my underlying point.
Donald Trump’s claim that Canada is actively “allowing millions and millions of people into the Country” and thereby “causing problems that will soon be too big to handle” is detached from reality.
As today’s report notes, Canada’s population growth over the past year was its slowest since 1915–16, and the smallest in absolute terms since 1945–46.
Canada does not need to reduce the amount of immigration it is currently allowing.
That does not mean Canada has not just experienced a period of very high immigration. It plainly has. Nor does it mean that immigration at those levels imposed no costs. It did.
It was also necessary, if mis-managed. But that's a debate for a different day.
The point that is immediately important is narrower. It is profoundly unhelpful for someone with Donald Trump’s platform—and power—to pretend that the exceptionally high immigration of recent years is still ongoing.
Someone in my replies compared my post to standing in a flooded kitchen and bragging that the water was turned off five minutes ago.
Fair enough. It ignores that the kitchen got flooded as we fought a fire... but that's part of the debate for a different day.
To extend that analogy; my issue is that there is also an idiot with the world’s largest megaphone standing in the kitchen, yelling that the water we shut off five minutes ago still needs to be turned off. That is genuinely unhelpful. He's refusing to stop, and getting everyone to focus on dealing with the real issues we now face requires informing everyone that his message isn't relevant to the reality we face.
That is the purpose of my post.
Canada experienced net negative migration in the first half of 2026. It is also currently below its historical unemployment average.
There are plenty of issues to discuss if you drill down deeper. But POTUS is not engaging with reality in this post.