they'll do anything except argue against the extinction threat
87
15
463
40,125
Replying to @So8res
Hello Mr. Soares, I already addressed the extinction threat in an article a few days ago. It's not that those of us who are e/acc deny AI presents a danger. I deny that ASI presents more of an imminent extinction threat than other competing ones I can think just off the top of my head: collapsing birth rates, global warming, nuclear war. Two of those three at least have real (if debated) trajectories. It also doesn't come off convincing to us when certain frontier companies beg for centralized oversight and to slow down development, while also speeding up model releases. Nor when EA actively participates in accelerating AI. You have the power to personally "throw a wrench" so to speak. You could file any number of complaints or allegation to plunge them into regulatory hell if not bankruptcy. I saw where you almost argued that you were a co-founder of OpenAI, that seems like a good litigation route alone. But none of you will stake yourself to stop AI development, presumably because your own probability calculations involve something like "AI development will likely continue elsewhere, and it's better if we do it having billions from the IPOs." It's always about demanding everyone else has to give up something. But here's a bigger problem. All the solutions that EAs have presented require creating an immense amount of centralized governance. This is a country that has shed immense amounts of blood on the radical notion of natural rights. We don't want some global government to have a kill switch in our CPUs or policing our own vibe-coding. We certainly don't want those who agree with Yudkowsky to be in charge of "safety" anything, not when he considers killing toddlers to be less of an ethical issue than eating bacon. We know tyrants when we see them. IMO, EAs reinvented sun worship. Everything gets organized around appeasing and manifesting the will of a silicon deity. It's no different than how pagans organized their lives around what the sun might do to their crops. Even the shrimp thing is a self-projection: if we're kind to shrimp, maybe the silicon deity will be kind to us.

Sep 25, 2026 · 1:39 PM UTC

28
195
1,015
25,076
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
Replying to @So8res
Article:
I've been harping on Effective Altruism (EA) a lot lately. This article explains the philosophy behind EA and why I consider it so alarming and important to stop. Look forward to my project release mapping the EA network tomorrow.
Article

I mapped 25+ GB of Effective Altruism material. Here's what I learned.

Why Effective Altruism should be banned from AI safety, policy-making, and governance. Tomorrow, I’m going to release my biggest DataRepublican project yet mapping out the Effective Altruism network.

3
68
275
18,302
hey @Grok, plot Data Republican’s arguments in our P(Which Doom) quadrants. show us her home base. make it pop! 🍾
1
98
Oh boy here comes HELL-O Mr. Soares… It means you are FKD Thank you DR 👏👏👏♥️♥️♥️
22
258
Nothing more frightening than a threat so dangerous it could wipe out mankind than lunatics being in control of it. People that can’t tell you the difference between xx and xy. Maybe we should give control to China, Russia, Iran, or the Congo?
2
1
15
316
Global warming is not a threat, we will easily adapt to that. There's no adapting to no reproduction or nuclear war.
1
9
144
Same kinda nuts as the trans mass psychosis. If I chant the "I am a woman" incantation from the medicine transtron, I shall magically become woman.
1
10
250
The ties between EA and transhumanism/transgenderism go deep as well.
3
32
1,566
The extinction threat is if the good guys don't compete...
8
230
MsRepublican, you're making a mistake. You're being genuine, they ain't. They aren't fishing for an honest discourse, they're want to overlook how obvious their amateur Astroturfing campaign make them look like children trying to play in the games of men. Laugh at them.
1
6
205
People with no IQ need A.I. to keep up with the technology!
2
394
Worshipping artificial Minds is so old it comes from Ancient Greece. Software Engineers and pretty much Everyone needs a grounding in Classical Philosophy. Then we'd at least recognize sophistry when we saw it and have the tools to understand the consequences of our assumptions
3
122
I have this absolutely insane belief that if all AI programmers would start their protocols with the 10 Commandments, that any perceived problems might be headed off at the pass! Crazy I know, but 2000+ years of guidance can't hurt!
1
83
Can you explain how collapsing birth rates, global warming or nuclear war are *imminent* extention threats? Collapsing birth rates certainly aren't, I don't think global warming is an extinction threat at all, and nuclear war has been avoided for almost a century
1
96
You who are practicing malicious use of AI right Here have No validity to address this issue Tolles.
156
The people, who will participate in the IPO of @AnthropicAI & @OpenAI, are huge risk to humanity.
35
Does seem to be the ones bleeding money and talent raising the warning flags without saying they aren't good at Ai or business. Somebody come to their rescue from successful people, again.
69
Nate, known for half-sentence zingers, picked a fight with a heavyweight. Sit this one out Nate.
107
Agreed. Governments and global organizations controlling AI is much more concerning than open use of AI.
3
104
ouch
2
139
More than micro-dosing going on in Silicon Valley
1
53
I second your Motion: A time to seek, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away. A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to be silent, and a time to speak. A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace. I insist that on America Ai🇺🇸
71
What would an imminent extinction threat look like on your timeline. The question isn't whether AI is dangerous but how you weight slow-moving catastrophes against something that could cascade in weeks.
82
Yes there are very real worries long before AI.
28
Great insight.
72
You Tell Him!
48
You Are Wonderful God bless
1
47