🇨🇦⚜️ polisci prof @mcgillu, Director Jean Monnet Centre Montreal; Rule of law, anticorruption, democracy; Book on Ru-Ukraine War: tinyurl.com/4zuhk9wr

Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Our book isn't straightforwardly about "war and peace", but about the regime and identity divergence between Ru and Ukraine, which Ru refuses to accept. We'll take the "hot new releases" label, though! Thanks, Amazon. @OxanaShevel @politybooks
25
97
315
102,423
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Not satisfied with murdering hundreds of thousands of Russian speaking Ukrainians, Putin now wants to murder Russian speaking Latvians, Lithuanians, and Estonians.
Putin claims that the rights of Russian speakers in Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia are being violated. You know Putin's lies. You know what happened four and a half years ago.
2
3
17
1,031
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Das sollten alle die auswendig lernen, die ständig Verhandlungen mit Moskau fordern. Der dt AM muss sich von niemanden, jedenfalls nicht von einem russischen Minister verhöhnen lassen, der zuhause in Moskau Zero Einfluss hat.
Lavrov on his conversation with German official Wadephul: When we met, I invited him to lay out the purpose of his visit. He took out his notes and read a text that was a verbatim repetition of what German leaders state officially and publicly on a daily basis. That is essentially what Mr. Wadephul told me. I gleaned nothing new from it. The subtext was something like: "I came to see you—I deigned to engage with you—so now, in return for this 'gesture of goodwill' on my part, you need to make concessions on the Ukrainian front and ensure an agreement regarding the Black Sea region so that tankers and dry-cargo ships can pass through without issues." Those ridiculous European clowns never cease to amuse 😂🤡
76
51
302
21,220
How do I put this politely? The leader of the opposition is making stuff up. No one is considering doing any of these things.
How does it save money for Canadians to force waitresses and welders to pay taxes to the EU?
3
6
15
937
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
“Russia is not my enemy”. Because it makes those other people suffer, not me.
9
66
362
5,116
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
“What if giving up has just as strong a deterrent effect as winning? I have no evidence this is true but we should act like it is.”
The most common argument for taking a hard line on the Ukraine war is that Putin is a bully who must be pushed back and fully rebuffed, so that he won't try something like this again. But what if, hypothetically, this deterrence goal is already achieved? What if the war has already gone so badly for Putin that he would never risk getting into such a situation again? People have this idea that Putin could stop the war at any time and retreat from the occupied territories, and that his refusal to do so shows he still hasn't learned that war doesn't pay. But I think this is a mistaken belief. If Putin were at this point to simply admit full defeat, it would be a huge blow to him. He could well lose power, and perhaps even his life. Maybe Putin would badly prefer to end the war, but has no realistic way of doing so that preserves his power at home. Recall that he initially thought he would win the war in a few days. In this model he made a big blunder, and now can't see a way to get out of the situation. If we consider this possibility, we should also consider that future wars may already be sufficiently deterred, even if Putin is allowed to keep the occupied territories and claim victory. That would let him stay in power, but it would not make new wars an attractive prospect, since he now knows they will be far harder and more personally dangerous than he first assumed. In other words, the deterrence that a defeat is supposed to deliver may already be in place without the defeat. If we are indeed in this situation, then continuing the war is a bad path that causes more death and destruction without a realistic route to a significantly better outcome. It burns many lives on the battlefield to achieve little more than we could already have. One could argue that a better outcome is still possible: fight long enough to force him to accept defeat. There are two objections to this. First, we must weigh what is gained from this against the enormous cost in other people's lives of trying to achieve it. Second, if admitting defeat would likely cost Putin his power and quite possibly his life, as argued above, then facing that prospect he may be tempted to escalate to nuclear warfare. So instead of a marginal improvement at best, this course could make things radically worse. I cannot prove that Putin has already been deterred, nor can anyone prove the opposite. Putin cannot tell the truth about his situation, and we cannot take him at his word. But if there is a significant possibility that he has been, then we ought to think hard and with an open mind before sacrificing many more lives.
1
3
22
1,772
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
this is a fact 👇
I don’t know if people realize that, but putin’s supporters outside Russia are dumber than actual putin’s supporters in Russia. 🇷🇺 🤡
1
2
43
815
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
UPDATED: Our @policy_mag Series on the Canada-EU Relationship, with new pieces by @Camillerilaw on Strasbourg as the third instalment of @MarkJCarney's "Europe Trilogy", and by Brian Wu on transatlantic protectionism... bit.ly/4AbfbMi With @Ailish_Campbell @Camillerilaw Brian Wu Peter Handley Jeremy Kinsman @PopovaProf & @DietlindS @DonaldColinRob1 @HonStephaneDion @alopezclaros & @Lisa_VanDusen #cdnpoli #EU
2
1
266
It's absurd that the self-styled proponents of "peace and diplomacy" and tireless opponents of arms and militarization criticize Ukraine--the side that has offered an *immediate and unconditional ceasefire*-- instead of Russia-- the aggressor who rejects it.
1
3
30
604
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Who was in Crimea with Konstantin Malofeev and Igor Girkin on 01.02.2014? Vladislav Surkov. Who was in Kyiv on 21.02.2014 and left three hours before Yanukovych? Surkov. Who was behind Borodai becoming “PM” of the DPR in May? Surkov. At some point, the pattern gets hard to miss.
21.02.2014: “Yanukovych will not remain in power under any circumstances.” Alexander Borodai states that Russia must withdraw its support for Yanukovych. The annexation of Crimea had begun the previous day, 20 February; seven days later, Borodai himself was in Crimea.
3
53
150
2,848
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
That word might be westsplaining
Every time Baltics speak about russian sabotage and military provocations, we get ignored, but the bigger countries just repeat our words louder and people start believing them. Pretty sure there is a word for behaviour like this.
2
5
21
1,315
In the 1990s, Ru couldn't hold one democratic election, its constitution-writing process ended in a shootout, it leveled Chechnya, occupied parts of Moldova/Georgia, supported the aggressor in the Yugoslav wars, but some fantasize about how it could've joined the EU. Laughable.
Replying to @RSA_Observer
Russia never wanted to become part of Europe. It always wanted to retake part or even all of Europe. Yeltsin told Clinton that clearly
2
18
87
1,903
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Der Kreml führt seit Dezember 1979 - Invasion Afghanistans - praktisch ununterbrochen Krieg an seinen Grenzen. Das "friedfertige" Russland.
Der „friedfertige“ Putin führte übrigens 1999-2009 Krieg gegen Tschetschenien, 2008 Krieg gegen Georgien, annektierte 2014 militärisch die Krim und intervenierte im Donbass, führte seit 2015 Krieg in Syrien und seit 2022 den Krieg gegen die Ukraine mit einer Großinvasion.
6
42
200
2,717
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
I should post a compilation of years of back-and-forth with editors around the world on behalf of Kasparov’s op-eds calling Putin a dictator and they’re trying to get it changed to president or strongman or other euphemism. Often they would blame their style guide. Cowards.
James Warren, executive editor of Newsguard, emails that when he went to bed last night the NYT hed was: “In Trump’s White House, China’s Dictator Is Welcome. American Media, Less So." This a.m.: “In Trump’s White House, China’s Strongman Is Welcome. American Media, Less So."
1
9
64
21,966
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Entirely predictable. Twitter does not consider calls for the death of Ukrainians to be violent speech.
18
68
474
4,276
Yes. Their ambitions are way bigger.
Given how conspicuously often Moscow has lately insisted that it has no intention of attacking NATO countries, a reminder: in 2023, Andrei Mordvichev, now Commander-in-Chief of Russia’s Ground Forces, said Ukraine was “only the beginning.”
2
3
20
932
We can see it clearly. Trump wants what Putin wants: Ukrainian surrender to russian demands.
Trump: You know what I want Zelensky to do? Make a deal. I want him to settle with Putin
3
21
91
2,000
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
Fukuyama: To end Russia's invasion of Ukraine I would give Ukr Patriot air defence missiles. I am enough of a realist to recognise that you sometimes deal with opponents that you cannot really negotiate with.
3
31
239
7,094
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
The main reason not to invite Putin to Miami is that he hates the US. For Putin, America and most of G20 countries are enemies; he talks to President Trump only because he considers him easy to manipulate.
Putin is responsible for launching a full-scale war of aggression against Ukraine. Why are we inviting him to the G20 Summit? It’s a betrayal of our service members, allies, and democracy, and we can’t stand for it. I’m demanding answers from @SecRubio and @SecScottBessent.
8
26
234
14,822
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
the "frontline" in Europe is not the Baltics. It's Germany
Looks like Ribbentrop and Molotov just gave each other a follow on Twitter.
12
53
285
21,629
Maria Popova 🇨🇦 retweeted
European politicians: Be like Sikorski.
118
710
3,561
38,787