Some more thoughts on the disgrace of NatCon in Jerusalem. Almost all of the conference was classic right-wing: immigration, family values, national identity, and security. On Wednesday night (Oct 7), the conference hosted a panel on the American "new right". The participants repeatedly shifted between brave truth-tellers and outsider non-experts just sharing vibes. What followed was a Groyper shitshow.
The panelists were all unanimous that Jews need to stop speaking about antisemitism. As one speaker put it (I may be paraphrasing), charges of being a Nazi have no currency today. When challenged (by me) on whether they think that there is real antisemitism, or real Nazis, and what the response should be, they offered no answer.
Let's be clear - antisemitism is real, and its not confined to the Left. In the past few years, there have been mass murders of Jews by neo-Nazis at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh (2018), the Poway Chabad Synagogue (2019). Neo-Nazis coordinated attacks on synagogues in the Northeast and Midwest in 2018. The FBI foiled plots against synagogues in Colorado in 2019. This is of course without getting into the new darlings of the right - Tucker, Fuentes, Candance Owens, Daryl Cooper. Do the panelists believe them to be antisemitic? Are we allowed to say so? They all implied that calling them out is a form of "cancel culture".
The panelists repeated objectively false reasons for the decline in support for Israel, and not simply as descriptors. Again and again, they said (some implicitly and some more explicitly) that Israel manipulates America into costly Middle Eastern wars. This is simply a lie. Over the past 50 years, the United States has gone to war to protect Kuwait, the Balkans, South Korea, the Philippines, Saudi Arabia and others. Americans have NEVER shed blood for Israel. Israel did not make the US conduct costly (and ultimately pointless) nation-building exercises in Iraq and Afghanistan. The recent was in Iran began when Trump promised Iranian protesters that "help is on the way". Israel, in fact, is probably America's most self-reliant and independent ally. Completely absent was any talk of American benefits to the alliance with Israel.
Then there was the usual canard about Israel taking American money. While I am sure most conference participants would support Israel weaning itself off of American aid, let's remember that the United States wants Israel to be reliant on aid as a tool of pressuring Israel. American aid is not charity - it must be invested in American technology and weapons. It is also being progressively phased out. Jordan and Egypt also receive over a billion dollar in foreign aid packages, but I've yet to hear hostility expressed towards these countries.
Finally, there was repeated talk of liberal Jewish American organizations, especially their support for immigration. The subtext was that Israeli Jews are somehow responsible for the policy choices of American Jews. As if there is some shadowy Jewish cabal to exploit America for Israel's sake. The worst of all speakers was William Wolfe, who I would venture to say was the only speaker who I would characterize as an actual Jew-hater. He spoke of "Jewish" voting priorities that hurt him as an American Christian, implying that his opposition to Israel is a means of getting back at them. Let's be clear - American Jews are American citizens, and have every right to promote their political preferences. Israelis have nothing to do with that.
Wolfe also believes that American Jews are conditional citizens. He spoke of pride of his ancestors having been in America since the Civil War, noting that no Jews signed the American constitution. So what? His implication was that they are not real or full Americans. (Somebody pointed out that Haim Solomon financed the Revolution). He also said that only one million Jews voted for Trump, out of 77 million Americans. Jews are the "junior partner" in conservatism and "need to know their place". He also spoke of his anger of American Jews largely voting Democratic. Again - so what? American Jews don't owe you anything.
Wolfe also claimed that he wanted an American-Israeli partnership devoid of religious or cultural meaning, purely transactional. And then he took Israel to task for selling drones to Azerbaijan, which in his words kill Christians in Armenia. Of course, Azerbaijan is a close ally of Israel, and sits on Iran's border. Armenia has close ties with Iran.
As an Orthodox Jew, its not my place to comment on Christian theology. But Wolfe took Evangelicals to task, saying that the "Old Testament" is a Christian book, for Christians, thus cutting off the Jewish roots of Christianity. In between the lines, Wolfe ascribes to classic supercessionism, in which Judaism has been replaced by Christianity and Jews have finished their historical role. That explains his antipathy to Israel and Zionism - the Jews are done and have no more right to statehood (or even existence as a group).
Hazony and co billed this event as having hard conversations, yet they objected to partipants who had serious concerns about the points raised, vigourously denying even the possibility of antisemitism or anti-Jewish undertones. Wolfe was combatant and intentionally provocative in private exchanges. He didn't come for conversation. He came for the applause of his Groyper twitter base at telling the Joos the truth to their face.
@NatConTalk is the right wing equivalent of Jews for Mamdani, putting their prefered policy preferences ahead of Jewish security and safety. Jews were silent as the Left was taken over by antizionists and extremists, for the sake of unity against the supposed greater enemy on the Right. This is the exact same dynamic that is happening of the Right.
@yhazony has brought Groypers to Jerusalem. It is a disgrace. Proud Jews and Zionists should not go along with it.
לְמַעַן צִיּוֹן לֹא אֶחֱשֶׁה וּלְמַעַן יְרוּשָׁלִַם לֹא אֶשְׁקוֹט