there are certain really dumb ideas that only smart people can believe this will never cease to fascinate me

Sep 21, 2026 路 9:56 PM UTC

7
22
2,129
George Orwell (author of 1984) said: "There are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them." and boy are we seeing that in full effect today really bright minds saying saying the most backward things when people call them out on it, the response is always the same "but look at my arguments! find flaws in my logic! look at all the times I've had brilliant deductions before!" if you've reached a conclusion that's obviously bs, but it has a 10,000 pages of supporting arguments, I don't need to wade thru all of them to call bs with the recent Navier-Stokes problem, we had a system of equations that simulate how fluids move we thought it was correct AI came up with an example where using that simulation and moving those fluids in a certain way accelerated them to infinity in other words we had a theory, and AI said "well, taken to it's logical conclusion we can stir a cup of coffee in such a way that it moves faster than the speed of light" ...whoops. we realized that was a BS conclusion and realized our reasoning was wrong not because we found where the equation was wrong, but because we realized that it led to a BS conclusion in other words, the dumb-ass conclusion of our reasoning WAS the proof that our reasoning was wrong remember this when people present assinine ideas and then want to debate you on them
1
2
9
648
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
Replying to @WesRoth
Two things 1. I'm out of the loop, what is the real incident you are discussing? 2. Has anybody tried storing the coffee in that way, just on the off chance that AI actually discovered infinite acceleration.
1
1
42
1. I'm being intentionally vague here 2. I keep trying and trying and trying... it just makes a mess
2
2
84
Replying to @WesRoth
Smartness is sorting out confusion. Being 'knowledgeable' doesn't necessarily prevent confusion. Being smart _and_ knowledgeable is what enables discernment about 'dumb ideas'. But then you may think differently: dumb ideas are logic boundaries, a path that hits a wall. Knowing about them and understanding them is maybe even smarter than simply calling them 'dumb'.
1
1
15
Replying to @WesRoth
could make an argument that they're not really smart then 馃槀
21
Replying to @WesRoth
Intelligence is often just sophisticated cope
9
Replying to @WesRoth
Well said! and are there really smart people, or people who believe they are smart because they know more than others in certain feild?
8