CEOs should absolutely use AI to help them make better decisions. But there’s a line we need to talk about. Ask, is AI thinking with you…or is it starting to think for you? 🤔
IBM recently found that 64% of CEOs are comfortable making major strategic decisions based on AI-generated input. Another study found that 62% of CEOs are using AI to make “most decisions.” And 46% of CEOs said they now rely on advice from AI more than that of their own leadership teams.
Beware of cognitive offloading, which can lead to a decline in critical thinking, judgement, and creativity, reinforce cognitive biases, and accelerate cognitive Darwinism.
Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla has talked about using AI when he’s wrestling with an important decision. He already has trusted people whose judgment he seeks out. Now, AI has become another perspective at the table…something that can challenge his assumptions, surface what he might have missed, and help him see a decision differently.
That’s augmentation, which helps lead to exponential capability.
Without intent and leadership, AI stops challenging our thinking and starts replacing it.
When we ask it what to believe instead of what we might be missing…
When polished answers become substitutes for curiosity, debate, reflection, experience, intuition, and judgment….
Honestly, that’s cognitive offloading.
And for leaders, the stakes are enormous.
The higher you rise in an organization, the more consequential your judgment becomes. So perhaps the goal shouldn’t be to outsource more thinking to AI. It should be to use AI to become a better thinker.
Use it to challenge your assumptions. Ask it to argue the other side. Surface blind spots. Model scenarios. Find signals you missed. Pressure-test the strategy.
But whatever you do, don’t surrender the responsibility, the gift, to think.
AI should increase your intelligence, not replace your intellectual agency.
The most important skill for an AI-era CEO may not be knowing how to get answers from AI. It may be knowing when not to accept them or when not to use AI at all.
I unpack this in less than three minutes. 👇