Defining Moment #14
Flores Go-Ahead HR vs. the Royals on September 20
by
@burghbulletin
As the cold, harsh reality that the Pirates wouldn’t be making the postseason in 2026 took over in the August and September months, a perception shift was needed for fans to still make the most out of the baseball that was left. Instead of sinking in the feelings of sadness and despair, it was important to understand that what remained of the 2026 campaign was still undoubtedly important as we look ahead into the future of the franchise.
Specifically, what makes a period at the end of the year like this special is finding and affirming answers in some of your younger pieces. Each additional at bat and game these guys get under their belts gets you one step closer to seeing how they truly fit in your organization moving forward. And in some cases, a guy can go out there and answer that question before you even have to.
(Meet Rafael Flores Jr.)
The Pirates acquired Flores Jr. from the Yankees back at the 2025 trade deadline as part of the David Bednar deal. At the time of the trade, Flores Jr. was the Yankees 8th ranked prospect. Given the circumstance of rather hopelessness surrounding the Pirates catching situation at the time, it felt like a respectable move to infuse the position with some young upside and talent.
Listed at 6’3, 233 lbs, Flores gives you a lot to like in terms of frame for being a catcher. His defense is certainly not a strong suit, but the bat is almost certainly what lured Cherington into dealing for him. Across several levels of MiLB in 2025, Flores Jr. finished with a .280 BA, 22 HRs, and an .825 OPS. The season before, he was even better, posting an .875 OPS in 2024 in the minors.
As a catcher myself, I hold high value towards catcher’s defense not only in the general areas – receiving, throwing, blocking, now ABS recognition – but also in the way they can work with pitchers and really help keep a staff under control. It’s a big reason why I’m normally not too critical of the Pirates sacrificing Davis’s bat in the lineup for Skenes starts. I do believe the psychological and overall emotional comforting ability a reliable backstop has for a pitcher is priceless, and it’s human nature that some pitchers work better with certain guys. With that being said, I think this is an area where Flores can make up for some of his deficiencies.
(The Breakout)
With Joey Bart being shipped out of town and Henry Davis once again having a putrid season at the plate, Endy Rodgriguez was the Pirates’ only saving grace at catcher. Endy was great in his time, posting 7 HRs and an .840 OPS in his 135 ABs, but he once again couldn’t escape the injury bug as he had several stints on the IL and finally underwent season-ending labrum surgery in August. As concerns arose over Endy’s ability to even catch moving forward given his fragility, Flores Jr.’s opportunity came.
Flores really struggled this season in Triple-A Indianapolis, a sharp contrast to his high production at the plate in the previous 2 years. Flores Jr. had a short stint with the Bucs in June as Henry Davis went on the paternity leave list and was then again recalled on July 8th. He had a rather pedestrian role in his first few weeks, and even suffered a concussion that sidelined him for the remainder of the month. He was activated on August 1st, and with the Pirates desperately needing help against left handed pitchers, Flores saw his role expand.
Flores Jr.’s first big day came against the Marlins on August 13th, where he blasted 2 home runs that accounted for 6 of the team’s 13 runs. Maybe even more impressive though, he masterfully worked behind the plate with Braxton Ashcraft to deliver one of the most dominant pitching performances we’ve ever seen from a Pirate. In just 85 pitches, Ashcraft fanned 10 Marlins and threw a complete game, just 1 HR shy of facing the minimum. As I mentioned, Flores’s ability to work with a guy like Ashcraft will be paramount to making up for some of his defensive inefficiencies and ensuring he’s in the lineup as much as possible.
Over the next several weeks, Flores continued to flourish. He knocked out 6 homers in August’s final 15 games, including another multi-homer game against the Tigers when he came in as a pinch hitter. Just wow. He continued working especially well with guys like Ashcraft and Jones, which are vital arms in the rotation to have under control. He was making a pretty good case for himself.
(Raffy Got the Royals)
Well, wouldn’t you know, he continued doing his thing as September rolled around. What was becoming especially evident was not only was the power playing, it was playing in huge moments in games and it was having a huge impact on the win-loss column. Maybe no example is better than what he did on the final homestand of the season.
As the Royals came to town for the second to last home series of the year, the Pirates were effectively eliminated from postseason contention that Friday night. That didn’t mean the games didn’t matter though, as the potential of finishing the season over .500 was still rather meaningful to most. Flores Jr. was a key contributor in the Pirates win over the Royals in the second game of the series on Saturday, going 2 for 3 with a double and a walk. Up two games to none, the Pirates had a grand opportunity for a sweep and to get their 79th win on Sunday.
Down 3-2 in the bottom of the 8th, the Pirates were facing the real possibility of another sweep slipping through their fingers. That was, until RFJ happened. Royals reliever Nate Pearson hung a 2-1 slider over the middle-third and Flores Jr. made him pay, sending a 426 ft. shot out into the left field seats at PNC Park. The Pirates would hold on and break out the brooms, as the young Flores delivered in yet another huge moment for his team down the stretch.
(Final Thoughts)
Finishing the season with an .858 OPS and 11 HRs over just 148 ABs, Rafael Flores Jr. has put himself in pole position to be the Pirates guy behind the plate in 2027. It’s possible that upon recovery Endy Rodriguez finds some time again back there, but it’s hard to envision a plan that doesn’t have Flores at the forefront of the position. Flores is the last part of the really encouraging trend I brought up in one of the previous columns, where we saw guys from the minor leagues not just come up and make an impact, but really take full advantage of the opportunities given to them and were catalysts for the team as a whole. It really feels like we have our starting catcher for the foreseeable future.
_____________________________________________
The Burgh Bulletin is a young, up and coming Pittsburgh sports fan who enjoys covering the Pirates as well as the other PGH teams and Penn State, in a variety of ways through writing, engagement, and media. Though the pain and suffering is real, there is no greater joy of his than getting to watch his Buccos’ annual (maybe not now) 162 game marathon over the spring and summer months, longing to see that extend into the fall. He hopes you’ll enjoy his work over the next few weeks of this series!
#LetsGoBucs