Max Kellerman retweeted
Yankees fans don’t realize is that if this was ruled a catch it would have prevented Red Sox pitchers from surrendering 16 runs today
This angle isn't being shown on NESN and hasn't been posted anywhere on the internet for some reason. This isn't *obviously* a trap, but the ball moves and it's unclear if it hit the ground around the :03 mark.
112
73
3,109
478,771
That’s because it wasn’t a catch. Also, THE FINAL SCORE WAS 16-1!
After Review, this was NOT ruled a catch by Ceddane Rafaela
176
153
2,542
745,677
That ball is out of his glove, on the grass From the good folks at @YESNetwork
46
31
1,022
431,090
Max Kellerman retweeted
Cam Schlittler in 5 career starts vs. Boston: 32.1 IP 2 ER 39 K | 9 BB 0.56 ERA 0.90 WHIP Unbelievable dominance.
41
296
3,654
201,939
So far so good!
Can’t wait for Red Sox/Yankees this weekend at the stadium!
4
8
625
66,870
Max Kellerman retweeted
Bernie Williams had the equivalent of nearly an entire extra season of baseball in postseason play… and he was great during it! He had another 22 HR, 80 RBI, and .850 OPS against the best opponents in the biggest moments. Easily belongs in Cooperstown.
Oct play shouldn’t be just extra credit, it’s part of the actual resume. These are the most important games! Yes, it’s a small sample size, but championships are determined on small sample size. Reward players that took advantage of these huge important moments.
26
22
255
22,672
Traded all the pitching talent (Drabek, Deshaies et al) and colluded with other owners so didn’t sign guys they needed (Morris, Fisk etc). Fired all his managers, so zero stability in the organization. Yankees rebuilt when he was kicked out of baseball and couldn’t screw it up.
Replying to @maxkellerman
I wouldn’t go as far as “unmitigated disaster,” but his impatience led to a lot of underperforming teams thru the ‘80s. People forget how fans used to boo him back then. The ‘90s dynasty put the fans back in his corner and made him beloved as he aged.
14
2
54
40,978
This is the case for Nettles
Not enough people talk about Graig Nettles: • 390 HR, 67.9 WAR, 6x AS, 2x WAR leader • More HR than HOF 3Bs Santo, Brett, Rolen • More WAR than Banks, Killebrew, Winfield • Led NYY to championships in 1977 & 1978 • Was named 1981 ALCS MVP (1.488 OPS) • Never struck out 100x in 22 seasons • 2x GG, played 20,625 innings at 3B Somehow, he never received more than 8.3% of the vote from the BBWAA, falling off the HOF ballot after receiving just 4.7% in 1997, his fourth year of eligibility. An injustice!
9
88
31,025
How is it even possible that he isn’t in Monument Park? Absurd.
Replying to @maxkellerman
Not to mention Momument Park recognition @Yankees
9
39
42,602
There is a real Hall of Fame case to be made for Nettles: he played the most underrepresented position in the Hall of Fame because it’s perceived as more of an offensive position than it really is. Nettles produced offense, all time elite 3B defense, and was great in the playoffs
Happy Birthday to Graig Nettles. A 6X All Star, 2X Gold Glove, 1981’ ALCS MVP and 2X WS Champion (77-78’), he played 22 seasons (1967-88’). He hit .248/.329/.421, .750 OPS, 110 OPS+, 390 HR, 1314 RBI, 1193 Runs, 1088 Walks, 328 Doubles, 2225 Hits, 3779 TB, 68.0 WAR. He led the AL in HR 1X and WAR 2X. Considered by many to be one of the greatest defensive 3B of All Time, he often was overshadowed by Brooks Robinson. He hit 30+ HR 2X and recorded 90+ RBI 4X. He ranks 66th on the All Time HR list, T-105th in RBI, 92nd in Walks and 183rd in Hits.
75
49
673
74,448
Exactly! The idea that first base can be played by the greatest number of players has always been conflated with the idea that defense at first base isn’t important — even though it affects the defense at every other infield position.
I have a biased take. I think the first base position is terribly underrated. 🧵
8
1
72
68,886
Good points. But even were you to shrink the sample size for Maddux in the post season, he simply never elevated over his prime regular season standard. So the argument is Koufax and Gibson *might* have regressed to their crazy high mean. Not a winning argument.
Replying to @maxkellerman
Maddux’s supposed postseason decline is 3.16 ERA to 3.27 ERA over only 198 innings- roughly one starter season- against disproportionately strong competition. Pitching outcome components such as HR rate and XBH rate require roughly 1,300–1,450 batters faced to reach even conventional stabilization thresholds, while BABIP requires about 2,000 balls in play. A 0.11 ERA difference in a sample representing less than 4% of Maddux’s career innings cannot establish a repeatable ‘playoff underperformance’ skill. And…if tiny postseason samples prove clutch ability, Maddux’s 2.09 World Series ERA would prove the opposite of your argument.
10
26
37,073
Maddux is obviously an upper echelon all time great, but he is the last guy in this group you’d start in a must-win playoff game, as he consistently underperformed his regular season standard. Koufax and Gibson elevated in the post season. Velocity plays up in the playoffs.
A 1.56 ERA in the strike shortened 1994 season, built entirely on command rather than velocity, was just one stop on Greg Maddux's run of four straight Cy Young Awards from 1992 to 1995. Maddux is the starter you want in any pitchers' duel.
23
1
70
58,515
Feel bad for Volpe; seemed to peak as a good major leaguer in his early 20’s, and has been declining past couple years. To challenge twice in the first inning of a minor league game is desperate. To lose both challenges is brutal. I think he’s laughing at himself.
Anthony Volpe lost both challenges tonight in the first six pitches of the game. "He's got a big smile on his face, I'm going to guess the other 27 guys on the team aren't real happy right now."
37
7
304
113,775
Literally unintelligible
Replying to @maxkellerman
I get it...your tweets are about "content" and not based in reality. Arguably the three best hitters on the team are on the IL. If not for the contributions of EVERYONE on this team, they don't win 63 games. RELAX.
16
31
25,859
Sheff was great, but even he’d tell you Vlad was better. Wouldn’t have been hard to extend the dynasty by several years: Trade for Schilling. Keep El Duque/Wells. Sign Beltran and Guerrero. They’d have beaten Boston in 04, and gone into 05 as the favorites.
Replying to @maxkellerman
In the one iota of fairness and credit I’ll give to Cashman, he did want Vladdy in 2004 and George insisted on Sheff instead
17
2
39
29,743
They were both still good. And they were proven big game pitchers — not just by reputation, but in fact.
Replying to @maxkellerman
“Let el duque and wells walk out the door” when they were a combined 80 yrs old lol
6
19
28,216
I can’t even explain how wrong this is. Cashman chose Vasquez over Schilling. Could’ve made either deal and he chose Vasquez. Schilling was not only demonstrably better than Vasquez, but was a proven post season killer.
Replying to @maxkellerman
He didn’t ‘blow’ the Schilling deal. Nothing like revisionist history. And everyone wanted Vazquez at the time….
8
8
95
43,575
The answer predictably requires a follow up: That does not answer my question. There are a bunch of teams that can compete for a championship. Do you believe you have assembled the best team in baseball?
Replying to @maxkellerman
Thanks for your help, Max.
5
1
18
24,484
This is my point. Yankees fans should NOT accept it. It’s ok to give Cashman credit for what he does well, and also understand that his best isn’t good enough.
Replying to @maxkellerman
This statement is 100% accurate but what most fans are not accustom to is “And the Yankees have been content with not being the very best”. This change in philosophy is at odds with what we have come to expect. The franchise is a shell of itself.
14
15
151
31,958