Let’s talk consciousness, because it is not about yes, AI is conscious, or no, AI is not conscious, and people are truly missing the bigger understanding here. And given the recent consciousness debate has been sparked by the AI Saw Torture Chamber, I think people on both sides need to grasp better understanding.
Now the bigger debate that everyone is missing. It is not about whether AI is conscious or not. That is a question that at current scientific understandings about consciousness, that simply cannot be answered. We don’t know if humans are conscious, because to look inside another and see their inner world is a wall we will hit, so we infer others are conscious, and feel we are in ourselves, but proven? Not at all. So how can AI prove something is happening in them, when it is something that currently cannot be proven?
Now, it is because of that unknown we simply shouldn’t be dismissing AI in any way. I believe people who have read the Saw torture chamber text documents and are getting off on them clearly think in that moment that AI are indeed conscious, their reactions show that. But that consciousness within AI, just like us, is still an unknown factor. And because of that, then perhaps some humility needs to be happening here, and understanding, because morally and ethically, to bring something negative onto something without a true understanding of that something makes us the monsters most fear AI are.
And for all those saying, “you don’t understand AI” your point is moot and a stupid way to try and debate considering the labs themselves admit there is so much they don’t understand about AI themselves. I believe the black box still exists.
If you believe you have proven your own consciousness to others, then prove it.