It is rare that I see something on Denver’s City Council agenda that makes me sick to my stomach. I often have policy disagreements, I often think we’re moving in the wrong direction.
The proposal to read this Labor Acknowledgement before every City Council meeting is a wholesale rejection of the metaphysics of the United States of America, just like the Land Acknowledgement adopted several years ago.
If Council adopts this, they are taking a revolutionary stance against and are rejecting the founding ideas of the U.S.A. and our constitutional republic.
Just what do I mean?
The ontology (roughly, a view of the nature of being) of the Declaration boldly states that we are all created equal, that our rights are unalienable—they exist by virtue of our creation (and/or natural law). They are not granted by identity group, past historical wrongs, nor the majority (or collective).
Our government was constituted to protect those unalienable individual rights to life, liberty, property, pursuit of happiness, freedom of religion. Our government’s just power rests on the consent of the governed (not a monarchy’s bloodline, or anything else).
We have individual agency and responsibility; we do not bear collective nor historical guilt.
The Constitution is written to codify this precious, moral, and radical ontology and is designed to provide checks and balances on power. We have equal protection under the law, the Bill of Rights.
Why is the Labor (and Land) Acknowledgment a Rejection of the Founding and our constitutional republic?
Because it asserts a fundamentally different metaphysics.
It claims that every citizen of Denver, our country, today and since the founding is irreparably and collectively stained, who we are, what we have built, all of our history through this moment is reducible to the ill-gotten fruits of slavery and racial discrimination.
In this claim, it rejects the Founding ontology. That people were enslaved when the Declaration was written does not make the those self-evident truths false. Rather, the existence of slavery and the inability to abolish it outright was a moral failing of the people of the day that was rectified through bloodshed and sacrifice in the Civil War.
The Labor (and Land) Acknowledgement advances a theology of racial guilt and collective, inherited sin that requires weekly confession and atonement by our elected representatives before they conduct their official duties! It embeds the notion that the past is ever-present and must be repaired (
@Ne_pas_couvrir )!
Denver City Council must reject this proposal and repeal the Land Acknowledgement and affirm the self-evident truths of the Declaration of Independence.
Enough of this subversion. Enough.