This is not the first time Guterres has made the insanely hyperbolic claim that the killing in Gaza is "unlike anything he has witnessed in his years as UN Secretary-General". He's been pumping essentially the same line for more than two years, and it remains as absurd today as it was the first time he invoked it.
Even if we take the Hamas-sourced figures at face value, Gaza's reported death toll is nowhere near the top of the list for the nearly ten years since Guterres took office in 2017.
According to the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data (ACLED) database, during that period approximately 275,000 fatalities have been reported in Ukraine, 203,000 in Afghanistan, 144,000 in Syria, 135,000 in Yemen, 106,000 in Myanmar and 94,000 in Nigeria - all well above the claimed Gaza figure.
So why keep making such grossly exaggerated and obviously false claims?
The reason is what I call "negative exceptionalism" - a compulsive tendency to describe virtually everything involving Israel in uniquely hyperbolic terms.
A terrible war cannot simply be terrible - it must be unprecedented.
The killing cannot simply be extensive - it must be unlike anything seen elsewhere.
Food shortages cannot simply be severe - they have to become an unimaginable "man-made famine", supposedly cramming "80% of the world's hungriest people" into one tiny place.
And this is where the pattern becomes self-reinforcing.
The claim that Gaza is uniquely horrific is used to justify an extraordinary, obsessive level of attention. And that obsessive attention then ensures that every death, every destroyed building and every individual tragedy is documented, broadcast and emotionally amplified on a scale no other conflict has ever received.
That unprecedented visibility is then mistaken for unprecedented severity.
The result is a spiral of ever-escalating demagoguery: the more Gaza is portrayed as uniquely horrific, the more attention it receives; the more attention it receives, the more uniquely horrific it appears; and that perception then becomes the justification for still more extreme rhetoric.
So negative exceptionalism drives the obsession, while the obsession continuously reinforces the negative exceptionalism.
It is long past time to break that toxic self-reinforcing loop.
That does not require minimizing Palestinian suffering or defending every aspect of Israel's conduct. What it does demand is abandoning the hysteria, restoring a sense of proportion, and reconnecting with reality as it actually is, rather than filtering everything through ideologically driven over-the-top theatrics.
This fucker says he’s never seen anything like Gaza in his life - well, it’s because you’ve never looked anywhere else you antisemitic POS.
@grok rank the global conflicts that have taken place during Guterres’s tenure by death toll.