vs Athletic Bilbao, 2015 Copa del Rey Final: probably the strongest case. He takes the ball near the halfway line, destroys multiple defenders on the right, cuts inside and scores. It finished 2nd in the 2015 Puskás voting.
vs Getafe, 2007: the Maradona-style goal. Starts inside his own half, beats basically the entire defense plus the goalkeeper. The Puskás Award did not exist yet, but if it had, this would have been an obvious contender.
vs Real Madrid, 2011 Champions League semifinal: runs through Madrid's defense and finishes past Casillas. Huge goal in a huge match.
vs Real Betis, 2019: the ridiculous first-time chipped finish from the edge of the box that hits the underside of the bar and goes in. It was nominated for the 2019 Puskás Award.
vs Bayern Munich, 2015: destroys Boateng with the famous change of direction, then chips Neuer. Iconic, although the dribble is more spectacular than the finish itself.