i just shipped `amp review` about 30 min ago. it has zero integration with github or PRs whatsoever and never will because i 100% agree with you. it's experimental, and it's also 5:45am and i need to get to sleep, but couldn't not reply when i saw this post.

I shipped deep code reviews in @RepoPrompt this week. Imo it provides the deepest codereviews because of how the app manages context for you. It supports git & jj, and you can invoke it from any agent either using mcp or the cli. It even uses claude code or codex to run it

the problem is i don't want more agent code review - i have that problem solved and feel good about the reviews i get from them - i need MY code reviews solved

I have a gift for you 🎁. Shipping Sunday I guess.

👀👀👀 lets gooooo!

Agreed! Iterating through GitHub kills your flow - we shipped the cubic CLI last week: docs.cubic.dev/ai-review/cli… Run cubic reviews locally - syncs all your memory, confirm, and custom agents

my issue is not agent/ai reviewing my code, its me reviewing its code

What specifically do you want to be better? Relative to, say, cursor review mode?

maybe cursor review mode is the play idk ive never installed it - can I oauth to cloudflares ai gateway

difftastic fixes this

it does not

the tricky part is knowing when to trigger review in local flow. after every function? after a feature? continuous feels noisy but batch feels like you lose context

Assuming you are using Claude Code you can run their PR review toolkit agents on your local branch changes before opening a PR github.com/anthropics/claude…

ai reviewing my code is not the problem, that's a solved problem. me reviewing ai code is the problem

check out github.com/jnsahaj/lumen/tre…

😉

So pre-commit tools like pre-commit.com/ and then something that gets a LLM opinion on the commit itself?

why do you feel the need to review code before it gets to github? curious because I often only review code once done in github for smaller tasks larger features?

You can run CodeRabbit via CLI and also through VS Code extension, so that is solved.

literally no x.com/dillon_mulroy/status/2…