I’m glad you found this clip, Thabo. Dr Blade Nzimande’s analysis is on point here.
The problem with Mr Mantashe is that he says the darnedest things, some of them very Trumpian, especially of late. For instance, only last month, instead of condemning outrightly the alleged sex-for-jobs accusations against his comrades in local government, he seemed to condone such practices by declaring that he and his party must not be involved in private sexual negotiations of people. This echoes the “grab them by the pussy” utterance of a degenerate American president.
Just as tone-deaf was his utterance that there are jobs out there but young South Africans are lazy; all they do is bask in the sun instead of doing what he himself did when many decades ago he went to “join” at TEBA and worked in the mines. He is saying this in the midst of the highest unemployment ever experienced in this country.
And who can forget his advice to South African men that instead of using physical violence on “their” women, they must instead use their “God-given sticks” - suggesting the use of sex as punishment, quite akin to war zones where sexual violence becomes a weapon of war?
Mr Mantashe’s utterances that he mistakes for wisdom, only serve to de-campaign the ANC. With leaders like him, Tambo’s movement doesn’t need enemies. I know two people who were regular ANC voters and were going to give the movement another chance at the ballot box after promises of renewal, who decided on the basis of Mantashe’s tone-deaf utterances (which they interpreted as arrogance) and the silence of his fellow leaders, that they were giving up on the movement. Of course this is anecdotal and is no evidence that his foolishness has cost the ANC massive support. But those two votes count and cannot be unique.
Obviously he seems to be happy that the ANC has become a rural party rather than a South African party of both the rural and urban areas. He says in as many words that the ANC should write-off urban South Africa and focus only on rural areas because he himself is from the village of Cala and he loves Cala because the people there are much more pleasant than urban people in the metros.
I am a rural development activist; I’m the last one to talk against a rural development approach to politics. But this foolish man is celebrating losing all the metros to other parties, and moving in the ZANU-PF direction which, according to Dr Nzimande, has become a rural party. He is not aware that he is fighting against the so-called renewal of the ANC and is advocating for its final demise.
Why do I come to that conclusion? ZANU-PF can survive for a while even as a rural party because in that country the majority of the voters (about 60%) still live in the rural areas as against the 40% of urban dwellers. In South Africa the majority of the citizens live in urban areas. According to the United Nations Population Division 64% of South Africans live in urban areas versus the 36% in the rural areas. And the country is urbanizing at a fast pace. Any attempt to celebrate, as this ANC leader is doing, the fact that the ANC has lost support in the metros and is now a rural party is to sound its death knell.
History has a way of teaching us to understand the unfolding present events and give us a glimpse of what the future MIGHT hold.
Listen to Ntate Nzimande.