The big Meta lawsuit out of LA, the $18B settlement where Meta admitted no wrongdoing - what does it mean? What will life be like in 5 years as a result? What precedents does it set? Will it help kids? Why did Meta's stock go up after the settlement?
TL;DR It's a smokescreen. It's a distraction. We need to watch Meta's next lobbying steps around age verification laws and the push to transfer their liability for harming kids onto other entities. Age verification systems require the fundamental underpinnings of centralized, individualized, automated censorship - controlling who is or is not allowed to see certain things. All the while, age verification doesn't solve any of the problems we're actually dealing with. Any potential solutions must pass the accountability test - the people best positioned to regulate parenting are parents themselves, and no one else. A child's health, safety and security are the responsibility of the child's parents/guardians. A non-consensual security-outsourcing arrangement is built on a false premise. Therefore it is irrelevant what anybody else thinks about how I parent, what rules I should have in my house, or what my kids do.
I put together my thoughts on some of it at
familyitguy.com/meta-settlem… and spoke with Julie Barrett
@CLADIESAMERICA about it at
piped.video/watch?v=rzqNBVqJ…
I also just got done reading
wsj.com/opinion/the-meta-set… - I recommend it, it's well thought through. Stuff like:
"We are protecting children's privacy by requiring a company to know more about them."
"The settlement is billed as empowering parents, and in places it does. But plenty of these decisions used to belong to parents alone, and now they don't."
"Teenagers have been dodging house rules since long before Mark Zuckerberg was born, and the fact that enforcement is hard doesn't mean the job transfers to a state attorney general."
"Social-media feeds are, among other things, distribution systems for speech. Rules governing how lawful information gets recommended or delivered can raise real constitutional questions."
And plenty more.
@Robert_Bork_Jr nailed it.