Is Resident Evil as good as they say, or just another failed adaptation? It's complicated... youtu.be/s-7wyeQyiCs?is=Z84W…

Sep 21, 2026 · 5:04 PM UTC

85
43
752
54,382
Sort replies: Relevant Recent Liked
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Knowing Cregger's movies, I predict the first half being decent and then falling off a high ass cliff
1
14
708
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Why it's complicated for Drinker: There is no message, there are no minorities as main characters or girl bosses. It's just a movie. And that's hard for grifter, i mean drinker, to cover.
7
14
724
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Zack: "It's for the fans of the game"
1
2
10
569
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I thought it was fun. The humor doesn't hit in a jokey way, but more like relatable reactions and his commentary that is similar to things I've said playing the game. Having played the game we know what is happening. our protagonist is just a regular schmo out of his league

ALT Charlie Day Ok GIF

4
1
9
565
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
From everything I've seen, it's not an adaptation at all. The 'Resident Evil' title seems to only be there for brand recognition.
7
127
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I enjoyed it. Starting to think I may be more of a horror-comedy type person than a gory horror for gore's sake type.
1
7
312
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
"a plot that isn't so much a cohesive story as a series of disjointed encounters strung together by the most bare-bones of connective tissue" pretty much describes every Zach Cregger movie.
7
263
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It’s a case of wrong story in the wrong world. Silent hill story in an RE world slathered in ill placed humor.
6
179
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I can get behind the movie for what it was, just like the Anderson movies. I didn't mind the moments of Bryan being sarcy and quippy as that was his character and he did have an personal arc with wanting the child with his girlfriend. But as a "Resident Evil" movie, sorry, but having a few references is never going to be enough to make me accept it as a "Resident Evil" movie. It was closer to being more of a John Carpenter's "The Thing" sequel, than anything to do with RE. This is what we get when new film makers try to put their stamp on a franchise with something fresh and new, ultimately pushing the fan base into the backseat and ignored. As a movie: 8-8.5/10 As Resident Evil movie: 3/10 It's frustrating being an RE fan right now.
5
407
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I didn't find it complicated to review this movie. After I saw it, I was quite angry. It's the worst video game movie retcon I've ever seen. Even the Super Mario Bros. 1993 movie and the likes of Uwe Bol give more lore shoutouts than Zach Cregger's RE. That's embarrassing...
5
265
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
More like "Tentacle Evil". It was Resident Evil in name only. Decent monster movie sure, but horrible RE movie. I hate it for using the Resident Evil name.
1
4
357
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I think this was just a message to the Hollywood “hey, we can make this franchise popular, just greenlight me.”, this movie feels more like a franchise teaser than anything.
3
347
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
If you took out the one mention of Umbrella and told the courier he was going to Chicago instead and the movie was called Pandemic or something else, you’d have no idea this was Resident Evil.
2
87
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I went and saw it this weekend, and enjoyed it. Was it perfect? No, but I think some are being a bit harsh in their criticisms. Like saying it’s a comedy. It has some jokes for moments of levity in a horror movie; that doesn’t make it a comedy. The only thing I didn’t like was it snowing in RC. Should’ve transitioned to rain, which would’ve been believable and tied in with the games.
1
164
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It's probably "fine" but the astroturfing is pretty blatant.
2
262
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Definitely took a turn at Racoon city (even tho some cool elements still). I like the monsters, for the most part, but there was no killing it. Even for side missions in the games, they have more lore. Not sure what the rules were but I like his directing and its well shot
1
251
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I liked it except when the ending went full goofy. I'm going to approach future Cregger movies knowing the ending is going to dial it up to 11, and it's not going to work for me, and that's fine
1
154
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It turns itself into a cringe comedy with cheap jumpscares after the first act. No, is not RE.
1
146
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It’s not complicated tho; it’s a shit film and a shit adaptation
1
109
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I actually did catch those references in the movie to the game and appreciated them as little nods, but yeah, the lead character was a bit annoying. I still enjoyed the movie.
39
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Is this a repost, because I would swear I saw this around a year ago. Guess the glitch caught up...
269
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I very much enjoyed it, but I’ve never really played any Resident Evil game, so I can’t comment on how faithful it is to the franchise (sounds like it’s not very).
1
426
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Horrible adaptation that has nothing to do with Resident Evil at all and instead tries to be its own thing rather than adapting the storyline or setting it steals its name from properly. There, simple. No need for shilling.
119
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Fun movie! Marketing missed the mark, but the quality carries it to success.
58
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Exponentially better than Resident Milla.
66
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Cool, I never played it. Might have to someday lol.
248
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Not much more complicated, I think Resident Evil must have its iconic characters, at least for a " " first " " adaptation
1
379
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
How many resident evils are we at now?
116
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Who made the movie? I don't think you said.
9
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Can we get some Ada???!
139
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I think it is absolutely a failure as an adaptation of Resident Evil. It is good if you like Zach Cregger's Reddit irony humor.
41
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It’s not complicated at all actually. You’re just doing your best to recover from being wrong when the trailer dropped and you tried poisoning the well. Didn’t work mate.
1
65
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It's good!!! Just don't go into it expecting them to retell a story from the game.
23
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
It was pretty funny and a nice ode to the games, wish it was longer, but it was funny
1
1
319
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
I feel like it's the opposite. -Is Resident Evil really as bad as they say? There seem to be more people bashing the movie than praising it. I personally had a great time!
1
509
Replying to @TheCriticalDri2
Mate I'd have given it 6 or 7/10 if it wasn't for the resident evil title. It was a comedy
1
91